Scythe ASHURA CPU Cooler Review

CPU Cooling by leeghoofd @ 2013-04-17

Japanese cooling giant Scythe has become a very popular brand amongst cooling enthusiasts. Their Mugen series coolers were a great balance between superior thermal dissipation and price. However these particular tower coolers were pretty humongous in design. Times evolve and installation issues with new enclosures and especially compatibility when installing heatspreader equipped RAMs, needed to be addressed. The noise generated also remains a critical factor when buying an aftermarket CPU cooler. Scythe's latest Ashura CPU cooler is on paper the perfect harmony off a high end tower cooler, with a slanted heatpipe design, cooled down by a powerful and silent 140mm fan.

Unpacking

The packaging is in typical Scythe style. Now where the PR team dig up all the names for their products remains a mystery to me. Even when looking it up on Wikipedia, it left me completely puzzled. Feel free to send a PM if you got it figured out.

 

 

 

The Scythe Ashura tower is a pretty big cooler, however this time the cooling surface is not purly determined by the height, but more achieved in width. The dimensions are 145 x 161 x 65mm ( W x H x D ).

 

 

 

The six 6mm heatpipes are of a slanted/assymetrical design, which de-centers the position of the fin based cooling surface from the CPU's center. A solution we have seen before and one that works to maximise RAM compatibility.

 

 

 

The specifications of the Ashura tower cooler are:

  • Intel Compatibility:
    Socket LGA2011
    Socket LGA775 (one position possible)
    Socket LGA1155
    Socket LGA1156
    Socket LGA1366
  • AMD Compatibility:
    Socket AM2
    Socket AM2+
    Socket AM3
    Socket AM3+
    Socket FM1/2

  • Dimensions:
    145 x 65 x 161mm / 5.71 x 2.56 x 6.34 inch

  • Weight:
    750 g / 26.46 oz (excl. fan)

 

Installation & Bundled Fan

Assembly is straight forward, in typical Scythe style. If you need to use the backplate, take your time to pick the right holes.

 

 

As you can see in the below picture, the backplate is well engineered, leaving no room for a possible short circuit with the protrusions on the backside of the motherboard. The new developed retention mechanism is over-dimensioned and assures a firm mounting of this huge cooler. Scythe includes the clips for the optional second 140 Glide Stream fan.

 

 

 

 

The 140mm fan has been named Hayabusa by the R&D team. Being PWM speed controlled, the RPM varies between 500-1300rpm. The airflow generated can raise up to 97,18CFM which is pretty high for a 140mm fan. Another feature of this Glide Stream 140 fan is that it uses compatible 120mm fan mounting holes, at 105mm. Each fan blade has added slits for less air resistance.

 

 

 

FAN Specifications:

  • Dimensions:
    140 x 140 x 25mm / 5.51 x 5.51 x 0.98 inch

  • Noise Level:
    13 - 30.7dBa

  • Air flow:
    63 - 165 m³/h / 37.37 - 97.18 CFM

  • Fan Speed:
    500-1300 rpm (PWM regulated)

  • Static Pressure:
    1.47 ~ 10.0 Pa / 0.15 ~ 1.02 mmH²O


Memory Compatibility

We already spotted Thermalright's solution, the slanted/asymmetrical heatpipes, to enhance RAM compatibility. Scythe uses a similar looking concept to displace the tower and fan from the centre of the CPU. A brilliant idea that will be adopted by many more aftermarket cooling manufacturers.

 

 

  

 

We tested the cooler's RAM compatibility on both the socket 1155 and S2011. No installation problems were encountered.

 

 

 

Test Setup and Methodology

S Sabretooth X79 motherboard
Intel i7-3960X OC'ed at 4500MHz 1.35Vcore
G.Skill 16GB 2133MHz C9 rams
Western Digital 1TB Green Caviar HDD
2 x ASUS Geforce GTX480 videocards
Corsair HX1000W Power supply
Corsair C70 Vengeance case
Prime95 is still our favourite CPU torture test. By selecting the Custom test and setting 12-12K we force the CPU to go straight flatout. After 30 minutes we verify in RealTemp the maximum load temperature results accross the 6 cores. For the idle temperatures we just let the sytem during 15 minutes warm up, practically doing nothing then just monitoring the temperatures. 
For the motherboard readouts we trust the ASUS Sabretooth Thermal Radar application, included in the AI suite. Reading out chipset, PWM, mobo temperatures, all these being monitored during the CPU torture test.
Noise measurement done via Corsairs Reviewers' Guide, measuring the generated noise at 1 meter from the fan front. Fans were hooked up straight to a PSU via a molex adapter. Noise tests were only conducted at 12V.
The Madshrimps testbed comprises of the following parts:
  • ASUS Sabretooth X79 motherboard
  • Intel i7-3960X stock and OC'ed at 4500MHz 1.35Vcore
  • G.Skill 16GB 2133MHz C9 rams
  • Western Digital 1TB Green Caviar HDD
  • ASUS Geforce GTX480 video card
  • Corsair HX1000W Power supply
  • Corsair C70 Vengeance case with Air Series Fans installed.
  • Ambient air temperature is 20°C

Prime95 is our CPU torture test. By selecting the Custom test and setting 12-12K, we force the CPU to go straight flat out. After 60 minutes we verify in RealTemp the maximum load temperature results across the 6 cores. For the idle temperatures we just allow the system to warm up during a period of 15 minutes. Just basic idling at either stock for the air cooled setups and/or 4500MHz for the AIO units, doing nothing more then just monitoring the temperatures.

The monitoring software we use is RealTemp version 3. And the output results are the average out of three runs.

We compare the brand new Scythe Ashura versus three other air coolers: the single fan Alpenföhn Matterhorn Pure (similar price league ), Thermalright True Spirit 120M and the Zalman XPS14, this chart is only with the I7-3960X at stock clocks (3900MHz due to the ASUS Turbo implementation). Once we add the different All In One Cooling liquid solutions in the mix,  the CPU speed gets cranked up to 4500MHz.

 

 

 

Noise measurement for the fans is done via Corsairs Air Fan Reviewers' Guide. Thus measuring the generated FAN noise at 1 meter from the Fan's front. Fans were hooked up straight to a PSU via a molex adapter. Noise tests are only conducted at 12V.


Temperature Results and Noise Test

From the quick compare with previous air coolers tested it's no surprise that the Scythe Ashura has got the best cards on paper. The large cooling surface and high flow 140mm FAN make this cooler shine versus the other three air coolers. At IDLE we see the new Scythe Ashura outperforming the rest. Best of all this is cooling performance comes at no noise cost at all. The 140mm Glide Stream fan is topping it all off.

 

 

Once we start to prime our hexacore CPU we see big differences pop up. The Thermalright True Spirit 120m with the smallest cooling surface has a hard time to keep things under control. Both the Alpenföhn Matternhorn Pure and Zalman XPS14 got pretty slow spinning fans and lack the airflow the Scythe 140mm Glide Stream fan produces.

 

 

Next step is to Overclock our i7-3970X to 4500MHz, by increasing the multiplier to 45X and setting the VCore at 1.35V. At idle we hardly spot any differences now between the air coolers, the 140mm FAN rotates at an inferior speed versus the other tested air coolers. Even tough the All In One Liquid coolers in the chart cool better, the noise level is already more pronounced then the Scythe Ashura.

 

 

When running the Prime95 test things heat up fast. The Scythe Ashura remaining the top performer of the listed air coolers. The Ashura is closing the gap between the Hydro units listed in the chart. while it might not look impressive at first glance it's the last chart that tells the difference.

 

 

The 140mm FAN shifts some serious air, yet remaining very comfortable for the ears. We measured 28dBa at 1 meter distance form the inlet, which is a great result. Especially comparing with the fans from e.g. the Hydro 80 unit. Even the 140mm version Fans from Corsair's brand new Hydro90/110 are clocking in at 34dBa.

 

Conclusion

Scythe's brand new Ashura cooler has proven to be a perfect blend between a high performing air cooler, offering maximum board/RAM compatibility and the great thermal dissipation capacity is not at the cost of any extra generated noise. In typical Scythe style, the retail price of this complete bundle remains pretty affordable too.

With the asymmetrical heatpipe design, the new Ashura is more versatile then comon upright heatpipe design tower coolers. Filling up the 4 dimm banks on our socket 1155 or the 8 on our socket 2011 testbed, did not pose any installation problems.

Due to the width of the cooler, installation on mATX boards can pose a problem (like it did with our ASUS Maximus V Gene board) with the graphics card installed in the first PCI-E slot. However installing a normal sized tower cooler is already pretty limited on the aforementioned platform.

 

 

The new retention mechanism is very durable and easy to install. Doing what is designed for, keeping  the big Ashura tower cooler firmly pressed down on your CPU, thus maximising heat transfer.

The 140mm Glide Stream fan is unlike some other silent 140mm versions very powerful and shifts some serious air. In the actual price range including one fan is normal. But it would be nice to see if Scythe would opt to include a second fan in e.g. the Ashura XL. The clips to attach an optional fan are included in the box.

The Scythe Ashura is a welcome addition to Scythes extensive line of air coolers. A new more versatile tower design, improved retention mechanism and big powerful 140mm fan makes the Ashura pretty awesome bang for the buck. While it might not be the best performing air cooler on the market, the combination of the good thermal performance, silent operation and retail price of around 45 euros make it pretty darn good value.

 

 

PROS:

  • powerful & silent 140mm fan
  • retail price (45 euros)
  • RAM compatibility
  • optional clips included

 

CONS:

  • second fan plz

 

 

I wish to thank the following people who made this review possible:

 

Sven & Rogier from ASUS for the X79 Sabertooth mainboard

Gareth from Corsair for the C70 Vengeance case

 

eTonix Media PR for supplying the ASHURA sample

  翻译: