GSKILL Extreme Series (HZ) DDR I PC4000 Dual Channel Review

Memory by KeithSuppe @ 2005-12-24

GSKILL?s foray into the Western overclocking community was explosive. While their early modules were ergonomically challenged; without heatspreader and barren, they packed quite a performance punch. Today we test the Extreme Performance PC4000 in 2048MB Dual Channel kit form.

Intro/Test system

GSKILL Extreme Series (HZ) DDR I PC4000 3-4-4-8 Dual Channel (2x1024MB)


Madshrimps (c)


GSKILL has labored to elevate themselves to the upper echelons of high performance SDRAM suppliers. Although a relative newcomer to the overclocking community, GSKILL has let their product do the talking for them and it's been quite the conversationalist. One of the earliest products reviewed here was GSKILL PC4800/PC3200 512MB kit. The memory performed as advertised and was the first product allowing me to reach a 300FSB. It's flexibility was ideal for the budding overclocker, offering the tightest timings available at DDR400 (2-2-2-5) and scaling to DDR600 running CL3-4-4-8. While the overclocking sector has probably grown ten-fold in the last few years, producing memory for what is primarily a niche market is no easy task. GSKILL does make memory for all applications; however, they continue their commitment to produce the fastest speed grades as IC's become available.

Madshrimps (c)


AMD Test System
CPU Althlon-64 3500 Retail Socket-939
Mainboard DFI LANPARTY UT nF4 Ultra-D
Memory GSKILL Extreme Series PC4000 (2x1024MB DC CL3-4-4-8)
Corsair TwinX2048-4000PT (2x1024MB DC CL3-4-4-8)
Mushkin XP4400 (2x512MB DC CL2.5-4-4-8)
Graphics AOpen Aeolus 7800GTX-DVD256
Power Supply PCPower&Cooling TurboCool 850 SSI
Cooling Alphacool CPU-waterblockNexXxos XP nickel plated. Alphacool pump AP1510 Centrifugal w/Voltage regulator. Alphacool CAPE Cora 642 passive radiators. 8/10mm Internal/external tubing
Operating System Windows XP


Madshrimps (c)


Under the Hood
I do not recommend opening or removing your heatspreaders, as this clearly violates the warranty, and can easily damage the memory. I wanted to identify these ICs for our readers and decided to take the risk. While the double sided tape shown cannot compete with thermal epoxy for heat transfer, it's a marked improvement over some thermal tape I’ve seen, which seems to act as insulators. GSKILL HZ series in 2048MB kit size spec' Samsung K4H510838C-UCCC ICs in 64Mx8 double sided. While they do not have the overclocking headroom of other Samsung parts, given the topology and the fact these are native DDR400 ICs, they do quite well.

Madshrimps (c)


Test methodology
GSKILL will be tested against two other brands of memory; Corsair TwinX2048-4000PT (CL3-4-4-8) 2x1024MB kit and Mushkin XP4400 (CL2.5-4-4-8) 2x512MB kit. Each memory, except for the Mushkin, will run using Serial Presence Detect (SPD or Auto in BIOS), since this setting is most commonly used among the average Desktop PC user. As overclockers, we must remember we represent a minority among PC-users, and as such, should be mindful of our propensity to tweak the BIOS. To represent or assist the largest number of PC-users, each 2048MB kit will be run under SPD (Auto in the BIOS) while testing at DDR400 and DDR500 speeds. Mushkin features SPD timings of 2.5-4-4-8, therefore this kit was manually adjusted to run at 3-4-4-8 for all tests. Above DDR500 each memory will run at 3-4-4-8.


Thumbnails below exemplify GSKILL FSB/memory ratios for each speed tested throughout this review.


Madshrimps (c) Madshrimps (c) Madshrimps (c)

Bandwidth Benchmarks

Bandwidth Benchmarks

Timings for each memory and at each particular speed are as follows;

11x200HTT
GSKILL PC4000 Extreme Series (2x1024MB) @ 3-3-3-7
Corsair TwinX2048-4000PT (2x1024Mb) @ 3-3-3-8
Mushkin XP4400 (2x512MB) @ 3-3-3-8

10x250HTT
GSKILL PC4000 Extreme Series (2x1024MB) @ 3-3-3-7
Corsair TwinX2048-4000PT (2x1024Mb) @ 3-4-4-8
Mushkin XP4400 (2x512MB) @ 3-4-4-8

9x265FHTT
GSKILL PC4000 Extreme Series (2x1024MB) @ 3-4-4-8
Corsair TwinX2048-4000PT (2x1024Mb) @ 3-4-4-8
Mushkin XP4400 (2x512MB) @ 3-4-4-8

These timings will be maintained throughout all benchmarks at each speed tested.

Beginning with SiSoftware Sandra 2005.SR3.

Madshrimps (c)


Sciencemark Membench


Madshrimps (c)


Lavalys
Everest Home Edition (READ/Write)


Madshrimps (c)


Xtreme Systems SuperPi Mod and Everest Latency


Madshrimps (c)


GSKILL has a slight advantage over the competition and while this is a prima facie result of latencies, all things are equal since Corsair's timings also result from setting the memory at SPD. Corsair was also rated at 3-4-4-8; however, under SP it ran at 3-3-38. This further supports a slight advantage with GSKILL. The system including BIOS version was unchanged ensuring no variables were introduced.

Onto 3D/System and Gaming benchmarks ->

3D/Gaming Benchmarks

Gaming Benchmarks

I noticed with certain programs, Doom3 in particular, 2048MB of system RAM does have an impact. Although today's graphic cards are equipped with ample on-board memory, GDDR3 memory and currently the fastest memory produced, second only to CPU on-die cache.

Futuremark PCMark05
1024x768 / NoAA NoAF


Madshrimps (c)


Futuremark 3DMark2001SE (330)
1024x768 / NoAA NoAF


Madshrimps (c)


Futuremark 3DMark05
1024x768 / NoAA NoAF


Madshrimps (c)


HardwareOC Far Cry Benchmark v1.4.1
Minimum details / Avg FPS (2) / Steam


Madshrimps (c)


ID Software DOOM3 Timedemo
Low Quality / 800x600 / FPS


Madshrimps (c)

Overclocking / Conclusion

Overclocking Benchmarks

GSKiLL outperformed Corsair TwinX2048-4000PT in the overclocking department running as high as 275MHz or DDR550. As stated in our intro, the nature of Samsung UCCC IC themselves isn’t so much at issue here, as their organization, double sided on the PCB. Regardless the overclocking prowess of this 2048MB surpasses any 2GB kit I've tested to date. Raising VDIMM with these modules will probably result in poor performance and does little increasing speed or tightening latencies. The benchmarks below include all GSKILL results including results at 275MHz. The memory would overclock higher, but was unstable in several benchmarks.

Madshrimps (c)


Madshrimps (c)


Madshrimps (c)


Madshrimps (c)


Madshrimps (c)


Madshrimps (c)


Madshrimps (c)


Madshrimps (c)


Madshrimps (c)


Madshrimps (c)


Price (at time of writing):
$199 Newegg
£149 Overclockers.UK
€279 BytesatWork.be

Conclusion

GSKILL F14000USU2-2GBHZ aka HZ series performed far beyond my expectations. GSKILL has come a long way in a short time since they began concentrating on the Enthusiast/Overclocking markets. Targeting a market segment populated with some of the most knowledgeable (often critical) consumers takes gumption. As Overclockers we are constantly looking for better deals and demanding better performance. We are a difficult crowd to please. Given the odds, GSKILL has most definitely earned a place among the most respected manufacturers of high-performance memory.

Albeit a minor detail, I couldn't help notice GSKILL's relatively recent ergonomic facelift in the form of an embossed logo. Early modules eschewed the added production cost of heatspreaders, which if implemented haphazardly does more harm then good anyway. Nonetherless, GSKILL waited until they had won a place in the hearts and DIMMs of the Overclocking community prior to focusing on aesthetics. In my mind this is indicative of a company concentrating on performance first, rather then marketing a product with fancy packaging and mediocre parts. Looks like GSKILL has been making all the right moves!

Pros
Excellent performance
Strong overclocking (especially for 2048MB kit)
Looks good
Value (price)


Cons
They could light up? (none really)

Questions/Comments : forum thread
  翻译: