Architecture

Saudi Arabia seeks to silence Neom project doubters with images and video

Saudi Arabia seeks to silence Neom project doubters with images and video
Trojena will have skiable slopes for three months during the winter
Trojena will have skiable slopes for three months during the winter
View 12 Images
Aquellum, a proposed region of Neom where people can live and work underground
1/12
Aquellum, a proposed region of Neom where people can live and work underground
Gidori, a proposed region of Neom, with breathtaking architecture and luxury living
2/12
Gidori, a proposed region of Neom, with breathtaking architecture and luxury living
"Jaumur will be an exclusive residential community set around an inspiring superyacht marina," according to the Neom website
3/12
"Jaumur will be an exclusive residential community set around an inspiring superyacht marina," according to the Neom website
Neom touts Sindalah as a global getaway, as well as a hub for yachting
4/12
Neom touts Sindalah as a global getaway, as well as a hub for yachting
Sindalah's shopping areas would look like this
5/12
Sindalah's shopping areas would look like this
Helicopter photo taken by Giles Pendleton showing recent work on The Line
6/12
Helicopter photo taken by Giles Pendleton showing recent work on The Line
Plans for The Line in Saudi Arabia
7/12
Plans for The Line in Saudi Arabia
Plans for The Line in Saudi Arabia
8/12
Plans for The Line in Saudi Arabia
The Line will be built one section at a time
9/12
The Line will be built one section at a time
"
10/12
"A luxury harbour destination designed for adventure and indulgence set amid tranquil lagoons and a stunning coral-rich shoreline," says the Neom website. Everything about Neom oozes luxury and money
Trojena is a mountain resort where it will have a more temperate climate year round
11/12
Trojena is a mountain resort where it will have a more temperate climate year round
Trojena will have skiable slopes for three months during the winter
12/12
Trojena will have skiable slopes for three months during the winter
View gallery - 12 images

In 2017, Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman Al Saud (MBS) announced audacious plans to build an extraordinarily ambitious 10,200-square-mile (26,500-sq-km) urban area called Neom at the northern tip of the Red Sea with a US$1.5-trillion budget.

Different regions of this sprawling urban area would include a floating industrial complex, an island tourist resort, a ski resort, and probably the most famous of all: The Line – a 105-mile-long (170-km), 660-ft-wide (200-m), 1,600-ft-tall (500-m) city. Yes, a 105-mile-long, 100-story skyscraper that will be home to nine million people in one of the most barren lands in the world. More on that later.

For reference, the One World Trade Center in New York City – the seventh tallest building in the world – stands at 1,776 feet (541 m) tall.

The intention is that Neom will be completed by 2039. Many experts are skeptical of the plan, and more recently, there have been many media outlets reporting that the project has been scaled back considerably. There's so much conflicting information going around on the internet that there's no agreed-upon amount of scaling back that we could find.

Helicopter photo taken by Giles Pendleton showing recent work on The Line
Helicopter photo taken by Giles Pendleton showing recent work on The Line

That being said, MBS is looking to assure the public and the project's investors that it hasn't back-tracked and everything is still going according to plan. That assurance takes the form of an initiative called "Ground X", which has been launched to prove that everything is still on track through photos and live webcams of progress on Neom.

Ground X reportedly has two million photos and live feeds of construction sites and project timelines for each of Neon's zones. However, it's not accessible by the general public, and is only available to investors and vendors. This type of 'transparency' bodes well for those putting up the dough. Sad for the merely curious.

Given that I'm effectively "general public" and lack the credentials to log into Ground X, some further digging led me to Chief Operating Officer of The Line at Neom, Giles Pendleton. He has a series of posts on LinkedIn titled "NEOM is real..." with the latest being "part 15", posted a month ago. "Lots of work visable [sic] across NEOM as camps emerge and infrastructure excavations are starting to show true scale of activities," he says.

Three months ago, in an edited post, Pendleton goes on to say "Latest progress video and despite the incorrect media reporting, another record month on the LINE with our excavation numbers..."

There's a two-minute video attached to his post that's worthy of a quick look. Some of the biggest excavators and dump trucks look like tiny ants within the massive construction zone of The Line in Neom.

Neom progress video

Nothing of this magnitude has ever been attempted. Sure, cities like New York City, Tokyo and Beijing are sprawling metropolises that could be considered marvels with the sheer amount of infrastructure required to keep them functioning day-to-day, but these are traditionally built cities that have grown over decades and decades.

"The masterplan for the LINE remains at 170km as we have always spoken about and we have always maintained it will be built in phases," Pendleton says in a post from three months ago. "We are working on Phase 1 which we will launch later this year. Nothing has changed. Imagine trying to build 170km or a city for 9m people all at once, that's like building New York or London in 1 go. It's impossible."

The Line will be built one section at a time
The Line will be built one section at a time

The Line is to be an entirely self-contained city, built between the walls of its 105-mile-long x 0.125-mile-wide x 0.31-mile-tall structure (169 x 200 x 500-m). No roads, no cars. Everything one could ever need within a 5-minute walk in a climate-controlled area. It will only be a 20-minute ride on the high-speed rail within its walls to traverse from one end to the other. Plans even include a soccer stadium with a 45,000-seat capacity for the 2034 World Cup within.

The Line will be powered entirely by the sun and the wind. It will even have its own government – more democratic, as opposed to Saudi Arabia's authoritarian government – in place to encourage tourism and diversity.

Plans for The Line in Saudi Arabia
Plans for The Line in Saudi Arabia

At least, that's the plan.

Among other plans for Neom are:

Trojena: a mountainous region with elevations from 4,921 ft (1,500 m) to 8,530 ft (2,600 m), making it the ideal place to put a massive ski resort with over 3,600 hotel rooms, an amphitheater, and retail and dining. It seems far-fetched to have a ski resort in an arid desert, but Neom promises three months of skiing in the Trojena resort every year.

Trojena is a mountain resort where it will have a more temperate climate year round
Trojena is a mountain resort where it will have a more temperate climate year round

Sindalah: a super-luxury resort island and yacht club on the Red Sea with world-class shopping and cuisine.

Oxagon: what appears to be a strategically placed floating port, complete with factories and offices and the like, powered 100% by renewable energy.

Magna: a 75-mile (120-km) coastal wildlife reserve sprinkled with 12 luxury tourist destinations along the way.

The list goes on ... and on: Leyja, Epicon, Siranna, Utamo, Norlana, Aquellum, Zardun, Xaynor, Elanan, Gidori, Treyam, Jaumur. These are all regions of Neom to "inspire, relax, create, find harmony with nature, stimulate your senses, recharge, discover, escape, transcend, adventure." It looks as though the PR team has used nearly a complete thesaurus to write the promotional content to describe the vision for Neom.

Most importantly, they forgot to include "bring us all your money," but it does seem implied.

Aquellum, a proposed region of Neom where people can live and work underground
Aquellum, a proposed region of Neom where people can live and work underground

This is direct from the Neom website regarding Aquellum, the region to be built 'encased within a mountain' along the Red Sea coast: "Aquellum will be a subterranean digitalized community of the future. Invisible from the outside, this hidden world will be driven by boundless imagination, inverting architectural principles to integrate with nature. It will seamlessly connect hotel accommodation, apartments, retail spaces, leisure and entertainment zones and innovative hubs."

The renderings of what Neom is supposed to be, or very well could be, are nothing if not amazing to look at. We'd love to see it in person when it's built. According to the Crown Prince, everything is still on track for 2039.

Source: Neom

View gallery - 12 images
17 comments
17 comments
Kaytown
I actually find it both disturbing and disgusting the amount of money and resources put into this when there are so many starving people on this planet, with wars primarily being fought over land and resources. Just think if the same amount of time, effort, and money were put towards solving real problems in the world today and investing in humanity's future instead of investing in this ridiculous venture.
martinwinlow
@Kaytown - Whilst I understand your feelings, you might as well wish for the tide to stop - very annoyingly - coming in and out and 'Just stay the heck still, can't you?!!!'... such is the nature of humanity. You just have to accept the rough with the smooth and try to concentrate on the potential positive outcomes from this monumental project.
As an engineer, I find it a very exciting and interesting plan and if it creates a useful living space for lots of people (from all walks of life) and manages to do so whilst enhancing the local environment (granted, a pretty tall order - but not impossible) then, why not? Would I want to live there? Heck, no!
I can think of a lot of other, way-less practical, ideas that have had *insane* amounts of money thrown at them - 'the hydrogen economy' (untold billons over the years, globally), for one! NASA actually doing something useful in terms of manned rocketry, for another. But I expect that line of business falls into the same category of human folly as Neom does in your eyes, no...? You've got to give people something to *dream* about, to inspire them to dedicate their working lives to achieve what might seem totally unachievable, today, but tomorrow...?
martinwinlow
I'm wondering why the first thing they did was not to build one or more temporary railways to convey all that sand from the build-site rather than use 1000's of trucks... or even a gigantic conveyor belt...
Excalibur
Sometimes I ponder over just how much timing matters in such cases.
For instance, we are at the cusp of a revolution in humanoid robotics and AI, by which I mean they would become generally affordable and reliable.
Just imagine if the workers on site were humanoid robots and automated trucks, diggers etc, and they all worked seamlessly.
The work might be completed much faster as they could work round the clock, without complaint. And thus possibly much of the up front outlay would be recouped in that way.
However I do not see the state of the art being practical (ex. extended battery life, robots with "pre-loaded" skill-sets for plastering, tile-laying, construction etc) for such uses before at least another 5 to 10 years.
@Kaytown Whilst I agree it is disgusting that we still have poverty in the world, I would argue that this type of project would lead to many lessons learnt that could then be applied to future such endeavours, to make them cheaper and better and faster. This is important as, the way I see things evolving, within a century or 2 at most humanity shall probably mainly be living in such structures anyway. They are definitely much more energy efficient than everyone living in his own house for sure, plus they cut down on transportation costs in a big way, and everything is within easy reach. Stuff of science fiction perhaps, but, bar a nuclear war that wipes us all out or sends us back to the stone age, it will surely happen.
fen
Any engineer from the western world who gets excited about this project should be reminded, their office in this place would likely be underground and far away from light, and they should go live in a hole now for 10 years and report back to us how it feels.

All the stuff like the marina, the ski slope, its for tourists, the people there wont make enough to buy a ticket. It also clearly says the people who live and work in the marina area will do so under ground. They will likely require a pass to come up to the surface for a walk around.
Rick O
Aside from the engineering challenges of such a project, how can there possibly be enough people in the world willing to pay the cost to live in such a place? This build will be spectacular, no matter the end result. Spectacular failure, or spectacular success.
kwalispecial
I kept help worrying that The Line would end up like a static version of Snow Piercer.
paul314
If it's delayed or fails, I wonder if the parts that do get built will end up like the ghost cities in China, or other overblown development projects that end up mostly inhabited by squatters.
Global
Show the reality & face the facts, energy, material & time to build, Oil powered? Mostly sand, labor force, tenants cost???
BlueOak
Fanciful renderings and claims aside, that sand hole looks little different, perhaps a bit bigger, versus the last time they showed it.
Load More
  翻译: