Ok so i completed this campaign a week ago and didn't know where to give feedback so i'm posting it here, i don't even know if anyone really cares or if this place is even right for feedback but if anyone's interested here's my feedback
the good:
1. the map and enviornment design are absolutely phenomenal, the way the cities are scaled up in size really make it feel more real and immersive.
2. the rpg quests like elements are awesome.
3. i personally loved the story
the bad:

Only one thing sucks in this campaign and that is the boring monotonous constants fights,
i get that that's how it supposed to feel given the story, your supposed to feel like your on the bad end against hordes of loth, but there has to be a better way to do that right. The way its done is that if you dont savescum, one mistake and you are softlocked and that would probably be fine if you didnt have to do the constant boring monotonous fights again and again which also last very long.

for example mission 2, the bandits before reaching grymm's sister, bad but still fine, the undead in the faey forest, getting more annoying now but it still feels very rewarding to do the prior things. but then the ultimate ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ arrives, constantly respawning loth weilders
with full armies while you have to suicide fight against a neutral army to thin them down so as to progress and the wielders respwan right next to it. maybe its easier to handle all this if one dosen't go into the city to fight grymm and get the spell damage tome, except good luck continously restarting in mission 4 to get atleast 2 spell damage boosting items otherwise i don't think one can last pretty long. All this while there's a time limit on your head and by the time the necromancers start running out of units, your gold reserves would already be depleted. Adding to it the exact same army composition of the enemy with only 2 different builds and man does it go from meaningful and rewarding to meaningless and boring and get it over with already please feelings.

Mission 3 while not ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ still equally boring and monotonous, just one more enemy build type and that's it , it would probably be fine if we fought them once or twice , but again and again same hordes of boring, one mistake and you are soflocked, monotonous battles.

Mission 4, Oh boy this one is a beast of its own, i wonder if anyone other than a caveman like me could even have the time and energy to beat this one, and that's a shame cause the city of windhaven is so nicely designed. most of the missions in this campaign i beat through by restarting after playing a little of the beginning and then savescumming. this mission i was very close to restarting the third time after reaching near the end because of the ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥.

The strategy on it is very simple. restart until you get atleast one spell damage boosting artifact. send elizabeth north with right troops (rana and maybe some bandits producing the right essence) full spell damage boost to fight against the chaos or arcane build weilders. keep swap ready and keep swapping out the troops they dimension door or swap in. later in the mission as the frequency increases keep falling back and swapping from the walls to the inner barricades during battles. similarly send godrick south to defend against the ranged and rats. similarly swapping and onslaught + the other spell destruction and order spell which gives all ranged units + 1 attack is key, first time i sent him north and almost died on seeing the ranged resistances as i thought the case would be similar south and elizabeth cant defend two places at once. Similarly torvald defends the harbor.

In the beginning this all seems good and balanced, though the boring monotonousness is still there, like ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ the elizabeth battles made me wanna cry as i kept waiting for arcane storm and acid cloud to kill the enemy while i keep the ones they swap or dimension door inside in place while ethereal scaling the meele troops or pacifying their troops. but i thought atleast it would not be ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ like mission 2, but oh man it slowly creeps up on you until reaching max climax near the end of the mission.

Near turn 50-55 i dont remember just before getting the prompt to escape to the harbour. you get attacked by 3 ARMIES in ONE turn all in the circumstances of 1. godrick being in the harbour to defend against grymm because torvald does not have the capability do to so anymore near the end (maybe because i built him badly but that essencse leech in the monastery in mission 2 is a TRAP) 2. elizabeth no longer having access to rana troops. I actually abandonded the harbour first time playing around turn 50 and suffered so much when i found out thats where you need to go to, thank god i regularly saved and also defended the harbour upto that point otherwise playing again from the beginning or middle is too much of a chore.

the 3 army attack is enough of a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ on its own, elizabeth loses most of her essence troops which she no longer has access to and torval, who's also inside to face the 3rd army automatically after elizabeth weakens, also loses most of his army. but then just a couple turns later another army full of high legions attacks you, now normally elizabeth takes these fights except she dosent have anything left and if torvald fights he will not kill even one enemy troop, well ok it takes time for the enemy to capture the fortress, you can head for the harbour during then and by then the objective also changes to the harbour, except when that happens it puts you right back inside the fortress and now you have to fight the defending army to get out, nice. at this point my brain was so exhausted i didnt even know how i got out of those softlocked saves, but somehow made it to the harbour with torvald and elizabeth both with some little troops but oh no, there is still one last thing waiting in the pier and its merkoth with a force that you have to thin out like the neutral army in mission 2 with suicide battles while not having any fortress battlefield advantages and being absolute broke and very little troops, nice.

Somehow using elizabeth to thin his army with spells and torvald to finish the job i finally completed the campaign and god help those who messed up their weilder's builds. This was the experience i had during the playthrough and it was much more painful than i have articulated here. Maybe a bit less and more meaningful battles would be more interesting instead of 25 stacks of bones and seneschals and 100 legionnares every other turn. Maybe i'm just not the target audience of this campaign and just suck that could also totally be possible tho.