EA Review:
Already liking the new improvements since DoS2, still buggy though as is to be expect in EA.
A point of criticism would be that i am not quite sure whether i like the randomness of rolling dice for almost everything, content gating behind rng rather than player decisions feels arbitrary and cheap for a video game even if its true to D&D rules. Those were made for a TTRPG after all.

Full Game Review: (for Hotfix 9 in Okt 2023):
After completing the game and doing almost everything there is to do in my first run (50/53 achievements) i can say that experience is weirdly backloaded and you can reach level 12 VERY early into act3 already. (I ended the game around 150.000 experience or so over level 12) As a cRPG and Divinity veteran i can also say that the number of items and DnD character builds allow for a good amount of minmaxing to the point where most if not all fights become pretty trivial even on tactician. (Maybe an enhanced edition will add a hardcore/honour mode)
For the average player this should not be the case because without minmaxing or mechanical experience the game should offer plenty of challenge.

Act3 sadly still features quite some bugs and incomplete features which i hope can be fixed in an Enhanced Edition with some extra polish, this doesnt ruin the experience really though since the game remains a great experience despite them and none of them are truely gamebreaking. (or not so to the detriment of the player) Also an epilogue or more fleshed out ending experience than we currently have would be amazing. The few endings i was able to see are fine conclusions but dont feel like they are memorable enough for such a huge game, at least it felt that way to me. (Its really hard to end games like these though, so i cant blame Larian for not perfecting everything, they produced an amazing and immensly large game after all)