Pros
-----
-A worthy successor of Jedi - Fallen Order in terms of gameplay, mechanics and story
-Familiar characters for people who follow Star Wars Verse
-Its cool to see Bode use his Jetpack
-The Coruscant level was fun despite FPS being in 40s, it didn't feel unsmooth overall even when the fps dipped to 25
-I like the game so far.
-They released a patch in sept 2023, which means they haven't given up on this game. I hope they release future performance patches that totally fix the issues.

Cons
------
- The planet level that follows Escape from Coruscant seems a bit boring even with fps staying at 60 but i had only played a little.

ADD - Post playing 23 hrs i can say that the game is a bucket load of fun
ADD#2 - 100% achievements seem to require a second play through and involve a bit of a grind. I won't be doing that, at least not for achievements.

Pros
-------
-First Proper Potterverse game IMO. At least my first proper Potter verse game.
-Very detailed Potterverse environments with a lot of iconic locations like Hogsmeade, Zonko's, Honeydukes, Three Broomsticks and Hogsmeade's version of Ollivanders'
-The Hogwarts Castle is very big, wonderful and detailed.
-Interesting main quest so far, elements of mystery about what is going on
-Likeable NPC mostly, some familiar names for those who have read the books
-No Bugs encountered so far, so a good port.

Cons
------
-Shader preparation on every bootup which takes about 2 minutes
-High GPU requirments, even with an RTX 3060 i can only play smoothish on medium settings RTX off
-My AV says high CPU usage during shader prep,
-- Gear slots are almost always inadequate since doing Merlin trial is cumbersome.

Conclusion
-----------------
barring few cons the game is well made and enjoyable overall and i heartily recommend it. 9/10. I am still enjoying the game.

add1 - 30 hrs+ into the game and it is still fun.
add2 - narrow minded views of the authors it would seem over the use of power, they don't know everything and are yet afraid to try new things(after 3rd trial), using ancient magic to blow stuff up is good but to heal its complicated and dangerous , such cliche,

add3 - in the end i decided to trust the keepers and keep the magic sealed away

p.s - i have read and reread books 1 -7, read tales of beedle the bard, seen the movies including fantastic beasts, yet to read quidditch through ages, cursed child and fantastic beasts and where to find them. i haven't followed potterverse much in past decade.