There has been a lot of speculation in the press about potential changes to pension legislation in the forthcoming Budget.
But remember, ‘politics is the art of choosing between the disastrous and the unpalatable.’
The link below is to the left wing think tank, the Institute of Fiscal Studies report on “Raising revenue from reform to pensions taxation.”
* Scare = abolish higher and additional rate tax relief on pension contributions. 😱
* Political reality = it would impact up to a million teachers, nurses and other public sector workers with defined benefits pension schemes. The IFS report uses an example of a nurse on £45,000 per annum facing an additional annual tax bill of £1,000. After just giving junior doctors significant pay rises to stop the strikes, hitting them with big tax bills would be “madness!” ✅
* Scare= reducing tax-free cash from £268,275 to £100,000. 😱
* Political reality= Levels of tax-free cash during my 27 years as an adviser: 1.5 times your total earnings, 25% of your pension value, £450,000, £375,000, £312,500, £268,750. HMRC have ALWAYS provided transitional protection for clients who have built significant pension funds. Retrospective taxation is in the “unpalatable" box. The IFS report concedes that unless this is implemented over a “generational time frame” it would involve retrospective taxation. ✅
* Scare= pensions will be subject to inheritance tax. 😱
* Political reality= pensions are investments in a discretionary trust, and have never been subject to IHT. (Pension funds had a death benefits charge prior to 2015.) The introduction of IHT could very well happen, but initially it doesn’t raise that much initially. “Potentially as much as £200 million a year in the short term.” The IFS report then states’ “Potentially as much as £2 billion a year, though probably less.” Accurate stuff! 😱
* Scare nobody is talking about = charge employer national insurance on pension contributions. Employers pay 13.8% NI on employees earnings and benefits, but not on pension contributions. ✅
* Political reality= applying employer NI to pension contributions is the most palatable way to raise immediate funds for the ‘black hole”. It’s not a tax on “working people’ To stop a ‘big-bang’ change that will simply risk a decline in contributions to pensions, the IFS suggest introducing a tapered system. ✅
The reason the Labour Party dropped the reintroduction of the lifetime allowance prior to the election was after consideration, the proposal was in the “too difficult” box.
I suspect many of the scare stories about pensions fall into the same casket! 📦✅
#pensions #tax #budget2024 #tax #getadvice #taxrisk #sjpwealth