How can school administrators use performance evaluations to improve teacher effectiveness?

Performance evaluations are a common tool for assessing and improving the quality of teaching in schools. However, not all evaluations are equally effective, and some may even have negative consequences for teacher motivation, retention, and student learning. How can school administrators use performance evaluations to improve teacher effectiveness? Here are some tips and best practices to consider.

1 Define clear and relevant criteria

The first step in designing a performance evaluation system is to define the criteria that will be used to measure teacher effectiveness. These criteria should be aligned with the school's vision, goals, and standards, as well as the expectations and needs of the students and the community. They should also be specific, observable, and measurable, and cover different aspects of teaching, such as planning, instruction, assessment, classroom management, and professional development.

Add your perspective

Dr. Seema Dutt

Principal at DAV PUBLIC SCHOOL
Report contribution
School administrators boost teacher effectiveness via performance evaluations, setting expectations in pre-evaluation meetings. Measures encompass classroom observations, student feedback, and test score analysis. Post-evaluation conferences provide crucial, constructive feedback, suggesting actionable insights and professional development. A culture of continuous improvement is fostered through regular feedback, collaborative goal-setting, and a supportive teacher environment. Tips include diverse evaluation methods, positive feedback emphasis, fairness, objectivity, and transparent evaluation processes. These practices enhance teacher effectiveness, cultivating an optimal learning environment for all students.

Like
Dr. Sotiris Hadjigeorgiou

Lecturer at College of Tourism and Hotel Management
Report contribution
School administrators can boost teacher effectiveness by setting achievable goals but as well comparable to close competitors. By doing this the administrator ("employer") should establish effective employment relationship with all stakeholders (for example students and teachers). The effectiveness of these relationships should be standing on mutuality between all stakeholders, for example on mutual benefit, mutual understanding, mutual responsibility etc. All stakeholders should be satisfied by this relationship. To that end an open and effective communication should be establish between all. Thanks

Like

2 Choose appropriate methods and sources

The second step is to choose the methods and sources that will be used to collect and analyze the data on teacher performance. These may include observations, portfolios, self-reports, student feedback, test scores, and peer reviews. The methods and sources should be valid, reliable, and fair, and provide a comprehensive and balanced picture of teacher strengths and areas for improvement. They should also be consistent, transparent, and timely, and involve multiple raters and perspectives.

Add your perspective

3 Provide constructive and timely feedback

The third step is to provide constructive and timely feedback to the teachers based on the evaluation results. Feedback should be specific, actionable, and supportive, and focus on the positive aspects as well as the areas for improvement. Feedback should also be delivered in a respectful and collaborative manner, and allow for dialogue and reflection. Feedback should be followed by concrete suggestions and resources for professional development and improvement.

Add your perspective

4 Link evaluation to professional development

The fourth step is to link the evaluation results to the professional development opportunities and incentives for the teachers. Professional development should be tailored to the individual needs and goals of the teachers, and based on the feedback and data from the evaluation. Professional development should also be relevant, engaging, and effective, and provide opportunities for learning, collaboration, and innovation. Incentives should be aligned with the evaluation criteria and the school's priorities, and reward excellence and improvement.

Add your perspective

5 Monitor and evaluate the system

The fifth step is to monitor and evaluate the performance evaluation system itself, and make adjustments as needed. Monitoring and evaluation should involve collecting and analyzing data on the implementation, outcomes, and impacts of the system, and soliciting feedback from the stakeholders. Monitoring and evaluation should also identify the strengths and weaknesses of the system, and the challenges and opportunities for improvement. Monitoring and evaluation should lead to continuous improvement and refinement of the system.

Add your perspective

6 Engage and empower the teachers

The sixth and final step is to engage and empower the teachers in the performance evaluation process, and foster a culture of trust, collaboration, and growth. Teachers should be involved in setting the criteria, methods, and goals for the evaluation, and have a voice and choice in their professional development. Teachers should also receive recognition and support for their achievements and efforts, and have access to mentoring, coaching, and peer learning. Teachers should be treated as professionals and partners in the performance evaluation process.

Add your perspective

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

Tara Hughes

Special Educator | Special Education Advocate | Data Driven | Love of Writing
Report contribution
In order to accomplish any goal, administrators need to support and back their teachers, above all else. When a teacher feels dismissed, micromanaged, or undermined, very little motivation will be left to go above and beyond. Teachers are working extensive hours outside of their contract to research and prepare effective, differentiated instruction. Sometimes there are rough days, there are lessons that won’t be perfect. To have that held against them when the latter is not a true representation, will not maintain positive rapport amongst administrators and staff. This will then domino into student performance as teachers are under too much pressure and stress.

Like
Sarafina Frans

Open to work: Language, culture, heritage, ICT, education and research enthusiast
Report contribution
Use feedback to detect strengths and weaknesses: One powerful skill that I apply as a teacher is using feedback to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the students. If students keep failing a certain subject, there might be a big weakness that needs to be detected and corrected. Teachers can do this through self-evaluation and repeating teaching content where students did not catch up well.

Like

How can school administrators use performance evaluations to improve teacher effectiveness?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Define clear and relevant criteria

2 Choose appropriate methods and sources

3 Provide constructive and timely feedback

4 Link evaluation to professional development

5 Monitor and evaluate the system

6 Engage and empower the teachers

7 Here’s what else to consider

K-12 Education

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on K-12 Education

More relevant reading

How can school administrators use performance evaluations to improve teacher effectiveness?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Define clear and relevant criteria

2 Choose appropriate methods and sources

3 Provide constructive and timely feedback

4 Link evaluation to professional development

5 Monitor and evaluate the system

6 Engage and empower the teachers

7 Here’s what else to consider

K-12 Education

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

Explore Other Skills