What do you do if your music recordings receive critical feedback?

Receiving critical feedback on your music can be a tough pill to swallow, but it's an integral part of growing as an artist in the music industry. When you put your heart and soul into your recordings, it's natural to hope for praise and adoration. Yet, criticism is not only inevitable; it's also a valuable tool for improvement. Whether it's your vocal performance, the mixing quality, or the originality of your compositions, feedback can shine a light on areas that may need refinement. Remember, even the most celebrated musicians have faced their share of negative reviews. The key is to approach criticism with an open mind and a proactive attitude.

1 Process It

When you first receive critical feedback, give yourself time to process it emotionally. It's okay to feel upset or defensive initially—these are natural reactions. However, once you've allowed yourself to experience these feelings, try to detach and view the feedback objectively. Consider the source and their expertise in the music industry. Not all criticism is equal; some may come from seasoned professionals, while other comments might be from casual listeners. By separating constructive criticism from mere opinion or unhelpful negativity, you can focus on the input that will truly help you grow as an artist.

Add your perspective

Joel Felsenstein

Autistic — Different Not Less | Entrepreneur | Musician | Educator | Speaker | Songwriter | Gamer | Featured in Forbes | Neurodiversity Ambassador
Report contribution
Receiving critical feedback on your music recordings can be disheartening, but it's also an opportunity for growth. First, take a step back and assess the feedback objectively. Look for constructive criticism that can help you improve. Embrace it as a chance to refine your skills and artistic vision. Don't let negative comments discourage you; instead, use them as fuel to push yourself further. Seek advice from mentors or peers, and don't be afraid to experiment and evolve as an artist. Remember, even the most successful musicians faced criticism on their journey to greatness.

Like

2 Reflect Deeply

Reflect deeply on the feedback you've received. Ask yourself what truths may lie within the criticism. Is there a recurring theme in the comments that points to a specific aspect of your music? Perhaps your lyrics lack depth, or your production sounds unpolished. Use this as an opportunity for self-assessment and to set goals for improvement. Don't rush this process; take the time to understand the underlying issues. Reflection can lead to revelations about your artistry and can help you make informed decisions about the direction of your future work.

Add your perspective

Jerome Renard

Mixing Hits For Global Artists - Working closely with their teams | 250M+ Streams | 2x Founder | Building for the Creator Economy
Report contribution
Reflect on the feedback. Not all feedback is good feedback. Separate what's "taste" and what's "constructive". From there you can asses what you need to do to adjust your work, or your processes

Like

3 Seek Clarity

If the feedback is vague or confusing, don't hesitate to seek clarity. Reach out to the person who offered the critique and ask for specific examples or suggestions for improvement. This dialogue can be incredibly beneficial, as it shows you're serious about your craft and willing to engage with your audience or peers. By understanding the precise aspects of your work that may need enhancement, you can make targeted efforts to improve those areas. Remember, seeking clarity is not about justifying your work but about gaining valuable insights that can propel your music forward.

Add your perspective

4 Plan Action

Once you have a clear understanding of the feedback, create an action plan. Identify the areas you agree need improvement and decide how you'll address them. Will you take vocal lessons to improve your range, collaborate with a different producer to refine your sound, or spend more time on songwriting? Set realistic goals and deadlines for yourself. Your action plan should be a roadmap that guides your growth, helping you to focus your energy on enhancing your skills and ultimately, your music.

Add your perspective

Jerome Renard

Mixing Hits For Global Artists - Working closely with their teams | 250M+ Streams | 2x Founder | Building for the Creator Economy
Report contribution
Feedback is useless if you don't act on it. Planing a review of the work you ask for feedback on will show respect to whoever you asked for feedback, but will also set you on a path of pushing you or your work further.

Like

5 Implement Changes

Implementation is where the real work begins. Start making the changes you've planned, whether that's practicing more often, experimenting with new techniques, or revising your material. Be patient with yourself—improvement takes time and persistence. Track your progress and be open to making further adjustments as you go. Remember that each step forward is a part of your evolution as an artist. Embrace the journey and celebrate small victories along the way.

Add your perspective

6 Gather Feedback

After implementing changes, it's important to gather new feedback. Share your revised work with a mix of individuals—those who provided the initial criticism and fresh ears. This will give you a sense of how your efforts are being received and whether the adjustments are having the desired effect. Be prepared for more feedback, and remember that this is a continuous cycle of growth. Each round of critique is an opportunity to refine your music further and solidify your place within the music industry.

Add your perspective

Carl Pickles

Professional Biologist, Enthusiastic Amateur Physicist and podcast presenter, scared by Chemistry
Report contribution
This is probably the most important. Music is subjective, but sound quality isn't (well, not as much). If you're being criticised for the sound quality, listen. If a small number of people criticise the songs, but you have a growing fan base, ignore it.

Like

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

What do you do if your music recordings receive critical feedback?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Process It

2 Reflect Deeply

3 Seek Clarity

4 Plan Action

5 Implement Changes

6 Gather Feedback

7 Here’s what else to consider

Music Industry

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Music Industry

More relevant reading