What are the potential risks of using artificial intelligence in libraries?

Artificial intelligence (AI) is a powerful tool that can enhance library services and operations, such as cataloging, discovery, reference, and outreach. However, AI also poses some potential risks that librarians need to be aware of and address. In this article, we will explore some of the ethical, legal, social, and technical challenges that AI may bring to libraries and how to mitigate them.

1 Ethical challenges

AI systems may have biases, errors, or hidden agendas that can affect the quality, accuracy, and fairness of the information and services they provide. For example, an AI-based recommender system may favor certain sources, genres, or viewpoints over others, or an AI-based chatbot may give misleading or inappropriate answers to users' queries. Librarians need to ensure that the AI systems they use or create are transparent, accountable, and aligned with the values and goals of the library and its users.

Add your perspective

Debjyoti Saha

Associate Data Analyst at SITA | Generative AI | Machine Learning | Data Analysis | Information Security | Power BI |
Report contribution
When it comes to ethical challenges few things come up in our mind such as biasing, privacy, transparency effect, security. When it comes to AI, they rely most on data, and the models in which they are trained can be biased. As said about training the models through data, if these data contains sensitive information then it may concern privacy. Training AI models require complex algorithms and this may be tricky to understand and may be the reason for lack of transparency. Security concerns, when the AI models turn their back. This may cause in making incorrect decisions. Lastly, ethical guidelines and regulations can help mitigate some of these risks and ensure that AI technologies are developed and deployed responsibly.

Like
Joyshree K.

Python developer 👩💻| Artificial intelligence and machine learning 🤖|Passionate UI/UX Designer 💻| AI & TECH content creator🎨 |Canva, Figma
Report contribution
Ethical challenges arise from potential biases in AI algorithms and the need to protect user privacy and intellectual freedom. Legally, libraries must navigate copyright issues and comply with data protection regulations. Socially, concerns about job displacement and equitable access must be addressed. Technically, data quality, interoperability, and algorithm transparency are key considerations. As AI continues to evolve, personalized services, chatbots, and predictive analytics offer exciting possibilities for libraries. Thoughtful planning and ethical decision-making are essential for successful integration. Libraries should establish clear guidelines to ensure that user data is handled responsibly and with respect for individual rights.

Like

2 Legal challenges

AI systems may raise legal issues such as privacy, copyright, data protection, and liability. For example, an AI-based facial recognition system may violate users' privacy rights, or an AI-based content creation system may infringe on the intellectual property rights of others. Librarians need to comply with the relevant laws and regulations that govern the use and development of AI, and respect the rights and interests of the stakeholders involved.

Add your perspective

3 Social challenges

AI systems may have social impacts such as displacing human workers, creating digital divides, or influencing users' behavior and preferences. For example, an AI-based automation system may replace some library staff roles, or an AI-based personalization system may create echo chambers or filter bubbles for users. Librarians need to assess the social implications of the AI systems they use or create, and ensure that they support human dignity, diversity, and inclusion.

Add your perspective

4 Technical challenges

AI systems may have technical limitations such as complexity, uncertainty, or vulnerability. For example, an AI-based natural language processing system may have difficulties understanding the context, nuance, or ambiguity of human language, or an AI-based security system may be susceptible to hacking or manipulation. Librarians need to understand the strengths and weaknesses of the AI systems they use or create, and ensure that they are reliable, robust, and secure.

Add your perspective

Abdelhakim ELFARKANE

Head Librarian | Translation, Copywriting, Project Management | Engaged observer
Report contribution
Using AI often involves collecting user data for analysis and personalization. Libraries must ensure transparency and user consent, while adhering to data protection regulations.

Like

5 Best practices

Librarians need to adopt best practices to use and develop AI responsibly and effectively. This includes evaluating the AI systems they use or create for quality, accuracy, fairness, and usability. Additionally, they should communicate the AI systems they use or create clearly and openly to their users and stakeholders. Moreover, librarians should educate themselves and their users about the benefits and challenges of AI while also collaborating with other librarians, researchers, developers, and policymakers to share knowledge and experiences on AI and its implications for libraries.

Add your perspective

6 Future trends

As AI becomes more advanced, pervasive, and autonomous, librarians must stay abreast of the latest trends and developments in order to leverage AI to enhance their services and operations, while also addressing the potential risks and impacts. Explainable AI seeks to make AI systems more transparent and understandable to humans, Responsible AI endeavors to make them more ethical and accountable, Human-centered AI focuses on making them compatible and complementary to humans, and Creative AI attempts to make AI systems capable of generating and expressing novel ideas.

Add your perspective

Abdelhakim ELFARKANE

Head Librarian | Translation, Copywriting, Project Management | Engaged observer
Report contribution
AI automation may replace some librarian roles, especially routine tasks. Libraries need to upskill staff and create new roles focusing on user engagement and AI oversight.

Like

7 Here’s what else to consider

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Add your perspective

What are the potential risks of using artificial intelligence in libraries?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Ethical challenges

2 Legal challenges

3 Social challenges

4 Technical challenges

5 Best practices

6 Future trends

7 Here’s what else to consider

Library Services

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

More articles on Library Services

More relevant reading

What are the potential risks of using artificial intelligence in libraries?

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

1 Ethical challenges

2 Legal challenges

3 Social challenges

4 Technical challenges

5 Best practices

6 Future trends

7 Here’s what else to consider

Library Services

Rate this article

Thanks for your feedback

Explore Other Skills