THIS IS EDITORIAL INTEGRITY IN ACTION.
Editor-in-Chief Joseph “Joey” Skelton issues “Retraction of: Body Mass Index and Gut Microbiome: A Cluster-Randomized, Controlled, Pilot Feasibility Study (doi: 10.1089/chi.2022.0171)” - https://lnkd.in/gTzkQ32U
The retraction was prompted by a letter to the editor from Yu Zhang, Colby Vorland, Lilian Golzarri Arroyo, and me (which can be viewed here https://lnkd.in/gkWr5qK6 ).
The editor wrote: “The Editor made the decision to retract the paper based on the following: (a) the distinction between a weakness or limitation in research vs invalid or incorrect methods is important; (b) weaknesses and limitations can be addressed by acknowledging them, whereas errors merit correction of the scientific record; and (c) the author response did not indicate that their original paper used correct and valid methods and it was therefore judged to be unreliable and meriting retraction.”
On the glass is half empty side, this is sadly another example of exaggerated evidence in the childhood obesity intervention literature (c.f: https://lnkd.in/ghqb9ndN ) and another example of invalid use of a cluster randomized trial (c.f: https://lnkd.in/gxqZNxsU ).
On the glass is half full side, this is a shining example of editorial courage in upholding the integrity of the scientific record.
Some who may wish to comment include: Diana Thomas, Moonseong Heo, J. Michael Oakes, Tapan Mehta, Jennifer Heimberg, Lehana Thabane, PhD, Gary Smith, Kevin Fontaine, Steven N. Goodman, Brian Nosek, Frank Harrell, Stephen Senn, Ayanbola Elegbe, Gwen Twillman, Nikhil Dhurandhar, Carmen Tekwe-Zoh, Christopher Lynch, Raphiel Murden, David L. Katz, MD, MPH, Dr David Ludwig, MD, Arne Astrup, Stan Young, Dan Larhammar, Layla Esposito, Stuart Buck, Wendy Chung, Lawrence Cheskin, James Sallis, Ted Kyle, Stanley Ulijaszek, Thorkild Sørensen, Berit L Heitmann, Carolyn Summerbell, Julia Belluz, Thomas Robinson, Anthony G. Comuzzie.
Image from: https://lnkd.in/gk3qkW7k