Co-Founder and Managing Partner, Agile 2 Academy; Executive level Agile and DevOps advisor and consultant; Lead author of Agile 2: The Next Iteration of Agile
In Reddit today: "...the agile teams have continued to have leadership mess..." More fully: "Over the year, the agile teams have continued to have leadership mess with the frameworks/guidelines in which to operate, thus somewhat diminishing my teams effectiveness. Recently, I was informed that they want the Scrum Masters to own the plan and delivery and be accountable for them." The reality is "Agile" is not pretty. Even if there is truth in some of the core ideas, those core ideas miss the most important things, and the whole ecosystem is broken. The Agile community confused "accountable" with "punishable" - not the same. The community confused "manager" with "pointy haired boss" - not the same. The community confused "timeline" with "death march" - not the same thing. The list of incorrect assumptions and flawed narratives is long. #agility #leadership
"The list of incorrect assumptions and flawed narratives is long." It's also heavily influenced by Scrum. For example, the idea of holding the team accountable and make it punish members who don't work hard enough is, in my view, as morally flawed as it is unrealistic.
Can't disagree, Cliff, there is some very woolly thinking in this space and not enough proper critical analysis. Somewhat amused by the "wanting to morph [Scrum Masters] into Project Managers" statement. I was at an organisation once that converted all their PMs into Scrum Masters again because the people making the decisions (leadership) didn't understand the domain at all or consider the consequences of their decisions.
Program Transformation and Development Demigod | Distribute Workforce Wizard pioneer | 200x Multiplier | Maj. General #GSD
9moGo ahead and translate that to some executives have decided that Software Delivery Manager is a natural "stretch role" for Scrum Masters--having absolutely no idea how to effectively support and leverage a Scrum Master so the entire business benefits--not just software delivery.