What's the better metric: Share of wallet or customer lifetime value (CLV)?
If you answered one vs. the other, you failed the test. The right answer is: Better metric for WHAT?
A new article in The Financial Brand from Lynnley Browning asks which of the two metrics is better for customer retention, and I'm firmly in the camp that while both metrics are valuable, share of wallet is a must-have metric in today's environment.
Lynnley cites a study that found that the "average" American had 5.3 bank accounts in 2019 (I bet Fifth Third bank LOVED that finding). While the # might be higher today, that statistic ignores the fact that many consumers--particularly those under the age 45--have 4 to 5 times as many financial relationships as the number of accounts they have.
Personally, I've never been a fan of the CLV metric. Is it a backwards looking metric or a forward looking metric? If it's forward looking, then you have to make some big assumptions about how the customer's "lifetime" is. Then you have to make some big assumptions about how effective your relationship development efforts are going to be.
Share of wallet isn't without it's shortcomings. The biggest shortcoming is that it typically measures dollars, and not activity.
If I were a bank or credit union executive, what I'd really want to know about my customers/members is their share of "engagement." It's nice to have account balances, but who and what are my customers/members using to make payments, and who and what are they using to manage their financial lives?
I did take note, by the way, that the article didn't bring up #NetPromoterScore as a metric for measuring customer retention. Good move, Lynnley! NPS is a totally useless metric. So sad to see so many execs put stock into that metric.
Got a preference between share of wallet and CLV? Let me know.
https://lnkd.in/eR4KP6Aq
💯 Jim Marous Bryan Clagett Mary Wisniewski Karen McDermott Joann Marsili, CFMP Alex Jimenez Willis Chang Derik Sutton Laurie McLachlan Patrick Reetz Dave Klavitter Lindsay Soergel Karen M. Kelly Lindsey Ogan Allan Switalski