As we approach the anniversary of October 7th, I am saddened and troubled by reports of student groups organizing events and inviting speakers to campuses that spread messages of hate and division. This day marks the horrific murder of over 1,200 people, including women, young adults, and children—the largest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust. It is also the day seven American hostages were taken, and those Americans remain in captivity to this day. Many students on these campuses have personal connections to those who were brutally killed or called into service as a result.
While I fully support free speech, we must recognize the difference between exercising this right and weaponizing it to hurt others. On campuses that claim to champion tolerance and inclusion, these events feel deeply disrespectful and divisive. Imagine the outrage if, on the first anniversary of 9/11, an event was held to demonize America and support terrorism while mourners still grieved.
October 7th should be a day of remembrance, mourning, and peace, not one that exacerbates pain. There is simply no need for an event advocating for Palestinians, however well-intentioned, to take place on that date.
Noah Stifelman, a student at Emory University, expressed this well in his op-ed regarding an event planned on his campus. He urged his peers to choose decency and humanity over unchecked free speech:
“Ultimately, this is a moral choice. Students must choose to resist the impulse to exercise their rights to the fullest in favor of creating space for collective grief. I ask that you, the leaders of ESJP, help our campus take one step closer to the healing and dialogue that are necessary if we are to be the generation to break the cycle of violence.”
Many campus leaders have chosen not to allow these events, while others look the other way. If leadership fails to uphold the values of respect, morality, and unity on this anniversary, students should reflect on the kind of community they want. How would they feel if their grief was undermined or dismissed in such a way? Ultimately, we choose whether to fuel division or foster a community rooted in empathy and mutual respect.