Bad science hits the headlines again, with another pointless study.
This week Daily Mail News publishes a completely taken out of context article based on a study carried out by The 5 Gyres Institute.
Let's clear up a few things from the article:
Article says: 'Bottles and cutlery made from 'bioplastics' are supposed to be #biodegradable'.
Science says: This is not true. #Biobased materials are fully or partially made from biological resources, rather than fossil based raw materials. They are not necessarily #biodegradable or #compostable.
Article says: Bioplastics are biodegradable but only under the correct circumstances.
Science says: This is true. Biodegradable materials biodegrade in certain conditions at their end of life - usually via #industrial #composting.
Article says: Left lying in the dirt or bobbing in the ocean, only some bioplastics broke down.
Science says: True. Depending on the material, and the conditions required for their degradation, if these conditions are not met, then they will not degrade.
Now on to the study, results, where researchers deposited 17 different bioplastics at 6 sites in California, Maine, and Florida - one on land and one at sea in each state. Mesh bags held the objects in place, while still exposing them to the elements. Land-based items were buried, and sea items were dangled into the water. Researchers retrieved the items at fixed periods to track how much they had broken down: 2 weeks, 4 weeks, 8 weeks, 16 weeks, 32 weeks, and 64 weeks. The study found that about 78 out of 102 bioplastic items remained intact.
The study is totally correct, but is also pointless. These #bioplastics will only fully degrade when subjected to the right conditions, which for these bioplastics is most likely to be via industrial composting - not being buried in soil or floating in water.
For clarification, #compostable plastics used in consumer applications should not be labelled solely as biodegradable. Whilst they are indeed biodegradable, biodegradability per se is an abstract and meaningless concept, unless it has a time and place within which biodegradability takes place. To better define biodegradability we should talk about compostability, i.e. within a space, time and industrial process. For packaging, the UK & European standard BS EN13432 defines this time, space, output, and toxicity. The UK adopted this standard in 2000.
https://lnkd.in/enmJHHKE
David Robert Newman FCIWM