I have a hypothesis that I have been refining since I became an editor for The Record and NorthJersey.com in 2016 and have focused on even more since I was laid off from Fox Business in 2021:
There is a crisis of mastery in the United States, which this cartoon highlights. We take our best and most talented and we let them languish in dead ends or force them to climb corporate hierarchies that take away meaning from their lives, or we place people with no skills except ladder climbing into these positions. This isn’t a new observation, but I don’t think the element of mastery has been a part of that discussion.
Corporate leaders treat exceptionally talented people with the same regard as they might treat someone who, in another time or place, would be working at the level of an apprentice. The system doesn’t incentivize, with rare exceptions, mastery. Because there is no financial gain in being good, or great, we get mediocrity in nearly every aspect of our lives.
Where there is room in some positions for mastery, on the other hand, there is little room for growth for others not elevated to those specific positions. Mastery should not be limited to spots on an organization chart. Rather it should be determined with the talent of the individual, who should be paid accordingly.
The question of mastery is then a question of protections for labor, which are being eroded and abolished where they can. In some ways, guild-like protections are necessary for the development and protection of white collar trades, like journalism or graphic design. And I am making a distinction between guilds and labor unions, the latter which are absolutely necessary and work in tandem with guilds. As I see it, a guild would include protections for freelancers and contractors who have specialized skill sets, like a bar association with labor protections.
The human spirit is demoralized by not being able to excel and not being recognized for that excellence.
People need to excel in their chosen professions and managment is not a profession.
Happy Labor Day.
A cartoon by Kendra Allenby. #NewYorkerCartoons
See more from this week’s issue: https://lnkd.in/gK5HXBzx