Mind blown during webinar by the American Academy of Arts & Sciences on "Achieving Civil Justice." The all-star panel featured Martha Minow, Daniel B. Rodriguez, Judge Diane P. Wood, John Levi, and Rebecca Sandefur, who described the four "Ts" of civil justice work: TIMELY, TARGETED, TRUSTWORTY, AND TRANSPARENT. One example hit home for me: The right to counsel in housing court, while a crucial advancement for tenant protection, sometimes misses the deeper issue: most tenants simply need a safe, habitable home or access to a rental assistance program to pay rental arrears. They don't actually want or need to navigate complex legal proceedings. When tenants face issues like lack of heat, mold, pest infestations, or rental arrears, their primary goal isn't to participate in litigation - it's to get these problems fixed quickly and efficiently.
The right to counsel approach assumes that lawyers are the answer in a "one size fits all" approach. In fact, while lawyers are essential in some cases, they are not necessary in others. And a lawyer-only solution is very difficult to scale and maintain.
Let's think about more upstream solutions. We should be investing equal energy in creating systems that prevent housing issues from escalating to the point where legal intervention becomes necessary.
We need a "Yes, and...," approach, not an "either/or." This calls to mind the analogy offered by Richard Susskind of the Black and Decker executive telling his employees that they sell holes, not drills. Lawyers are drills. Holes are the solutions. Sometimes lawyers create the solutions. Sometimes they cant. We should be thinking about solutions.
#rtc #accesstojustice #righttocounsel
Of Counsel, Krieg DeVault LLP, Governmental Affairs and Public Advocacy Practice
2moIt was a great event!