Choosing to get a PhD does not mean committing to a career in academia.
You aren't breaking any promises by considering a variety of career paths.
But I can see how it would feel that way.
I had the opportunity to participate in a careers panel yesterday at the University of Minnesota, Twin Cities, and we had a wonderful and wide-ranging discussion about careers for PhDs.
A key observation that came out of our conversation was that PhD students do recognize that there are multiple career paths, but feel that they’ve already picked one.
They have chosen and committed to a career in academia by enrolling in a PhD program.
This makes sense. After all, academia is built on an apprenticeship model.
The key components of an apprenticeship are direct business involvement (PhD programs are designed and run by universities), on-the-job training (students have an expert mentor to train them), related instruction (students complete coursework), rewards for skill gains (this one is iffy, but there’s often a stipend bump when students reach candidacy), and completion resulting in a national occupation credential (a PhD!).
The only problem is that apprenticeship is supposed to prepare you for a high-quality, well-paying job that is in demand.
Professors are not in demand.
Grad programs can’t offer a stable, tenure-track faculty role at the end of a 5+ year apprenticeship, so grad students should not be expected to act as though they are committing to such a role.
There is still immense value to be gained in PhD programs, but to fully take advantage of that value, grad students need opportunities to apply their skills to non-academic projects and to receive mentorship from professionals outside the academy.
Choosing to get a PhD means committing to an education, not a career. An education that will help you learn, grow, and build valuable skills that you can continue to develop in any career path you choose.
Thank you to Evan Block for organizing and to Katelin Krieg, PhD and Mackenzie Sullivan for being fantastic co-panelists!
#RecoveringAcademics #LeavingAcademia