How to Shortlist Top HR Talent for Interview

Recruiting the right talent for your HR team is critical to the overall success of your organisation. But it’s not just about finding someone with the right skills it’s about identifying candidates who can excel within your specific organisational culture and make a measurable impact. Here’s a structured approach to evaluating HR candidates to ensure you find the best fit for your team and business needs

1. Define Your Criteria

Before starting your recruitment process, it’s essential to define what success looks like in the role. Begin by analysing your current HR team’s high performers and those who have left but thrived in their new roles. Identifying where these successful individuals went and what roles they transitioned into can give you insights into the skill sets that drove their success. Use these insights to shape your performance-based job descriptions , ensuring that the key outcomes and duties you want candidates to achieve are clearly defined.

2. Experience in a Similar Structure

Understanding a candidate’s experience within different HR structures is crucial. Evaluate whether the candidate has worked in similar HR models, such as HR Generalist roles, Centre of Excellence (COE), or HR Business Partner, COE Shared Services . Additionally, assess whether they have supported similar business units and stakeholders in environments like MNCs, SMEs, or Start ups. Finally, ensure their experience matches your organisation’s headcount and complexity, which will impact their ability to manage and adapt.

3. Experience & Key Achievements

The next step is to examine the candidate’s past experience and achievements. It’s not enough for someone to have held similar roles they need to have excelled in them. Look for key achievements that demonstrate their ability to drive commercial impact, show leadership influence, or deliver successful projects. More importantly, can the candidate demonstrate a deep understanding of the business beyond HR? Look for evidence of data-driven decision-making that positively impacted overall company performance.

4. Leadership Capabilities

A candidate’s leadership skills can often be the differentiator between someone who performs well and someone who drives real change. Assess their career progression, have they been promoted into positions of greater responsibility? This will help you understand their leadership potential. Additionally, consider whether they have led cross-functional initiatives, particularly those involving senior stakeholders. Finally, look for evidence that they have developed or coached successful teams

5. Cultural Fit

Cultural fit is just as important as experience and achievements when assessing HR candidates. Does the candidate’s personal and professional values align with your company’s culture? This alignment is often key to long-term success. Additionally, examine their adaptability can they show examples of thriving in different corporate cultures or transitioning between industries? Lastly, have a look at the LinkedIn profile, what do they share? What do they care about?

6. Things to look out for

It’s equally important to be aware of things that could signal potential issues. Frequent job changes without substantial achievements may indicate a lack of commitment or adaptability. Candidates who list similar responsibilities across multiple roles without demonstrating growth or increased responsibility may have stagnated in their careers. Lastly, if a candidate is unable to show how their HR initiatives tied back to business results or data, this could suggest a gap in their commercial acumen an increasingly important skill in HR.

Conclusion

By taking a structured approach to evaluating HR candidates, you can ensure that you are not only hiring someone with the right skills but someone who can thrive in your organisation. Defining your criteria, looking at their experience within similar structures, assessing key achievements, evaluating leadership capabilities, and ensuring cultural fit will help you make informed hiring decisions. In my experience HR is transferable between industry sectors so don't use this as a defining criteria. Some of the best hires I have made have been candidates that don't look great on paper. So If you are 50/50 pickup the phone and speak to the candidates sometimes a short conversation can be the best decision you can make.

How do you shortlist top talent?

Follow the steps below to receive access to all our Hi Res Cheat Sheets + free Hiring, Leadership & Career Advice to help you develop your, HR career and life.

1. Follow Martin Hill  

2. Share with your network 

3. Subscribe to On HR's Radar Newsletter 

https://lnkd.in/dWmPu9fU