When Traditional Product Tweaks Fail: Understanding the Subconscious Drivers of Consumer Behavior

In every company, there are product experts—individuals who possess deep knowledge of the product’s history, its evolution, and the competitive landscape. They can articulate the nuances in regional preferences and understand the subtle variations in consumer expectations. These experts are the go-to team when a product begins to lose its market edge. They are called upon to make those crucial tweaks—adjusting flavors, modifying packaging, or fine-tuning marketing messages—to recapture consumer preference and restore market position. And historically, they succeed.

But what happens when these time-tested strategies don’t work? When despite careful adjustments and positive preference testing, your market share continues to erode?

The issue is rarely a matter of expertise. Your product experts are as skilled as ever, applying the same methods that have proven successful in the past. The problem likely lies elsewhere—in a fundamental shift in the market, in consumer attitudes, and in expectations. The consumer is now seeking something different from your product, something that cannot be addressed by merely adjusting the sweetness, bitterness, or flavor intensity.

Such shifts occur more often than one might expect. Media coverage on health, environmental impact, or ethical sourcing can reshape consumer perceptions overnight. A new competitor may redefine what consumers expect from the category. External shocks, such as a global pandemic or economic downturn, can dramatically alter consumer behavior. In these situations, the tried-and-true formula of incremental product adjustments fails to resonate because the consumer’s deeper needs and desires have changed.

The challenge is that consumers themselves may not fully realize this shift. They might still express satisfaction with your product when asked directly, yet their purchasing behavior tells a different story. The familiar product they once loved now feels out of date; another brand suddenly seems more appealing.

This scenario signals a paradigm shift, one that cannot be captured through traditional metrics alone. Declining sales may be the first indication, but the root cause is psychological—a change in the consumer’s subconscious drivers. To address this, you must go beyond surface-level observations and delve into the emotional journey of your consumers. Understanding how their sensory experiences align (or misalign) with their updated expectations is crucial.

To truly grasp these shifts, you need a different approach—one that tracks and decodes the emotional and psychological responses of consumers to your product. This means identifying where your brand falls short of their revised expectations and discovering how you can realign your sensory delivery and communications to meet these new demands.

When your usual strategies are failing, it’s a signal that something deeper is at play. By embracing a more nuanced approach to understanding consumer psychology, you can uncover the subconscious drivers that influence behavior and make the necessary adjustments to maintain your brand’s relevance and appeal.

This version emphasizes the importance of understanding subconscious consumer motivations and how shifts in these deeper drivers can render traditional product adjustments ineffective. It also stresses the need for F&B professionals to adopt a more psychological approach to consumer research to stay ahead of market changes.

If you liked this article, you can read more here

Chris Lukehurst is a Consumer Psychologist and a Director at The Marketing Clinic:

Providing Clarity on the Psychological relationships between consumers and brands