John Crace: Our discussion of episode one provoked some interesting thoughts - so how does the rest of the drama measure up?

John Crace: Alan Bleasdale's political drama isn't quite the shocker it once was but the screenplay is taut and the acting spot on

Charlotte Higgins: It has dodgy sets (and wigs) but what makes I, Claudius great is the seminal acting and writing

Esther Addley: Lawlessness, unexpected murders, strong women, impressive moustaches – Deadwood is so much more than just a western

John Crace: Was Edge of Darkness really one of the top 50 television dramas of all time? Not on the evidence of the final three episodes

John Crace: There was plenty of evidence in episode one to back up Edge of Darkness' stellar reputation. So is the standard maintained in episodes two and three?

John Crace: Is Edge of Darkness a televisual masterpiece? Many of you told us it was. So we're breaking out the DVDs and watching it again – and we want you to join the discussion

Tim Lusher: Annoyed that your favourite show wasn't in our list of the 50 TV dramas of all time? Join us to watch and discuss some of the shows you say we missed