28 people found this review helpful
Recommended
0.0 hrs last two weeks / 5.1 hrs on record
Posted: 5 Aug, 2017 @ 8:06pm

I've played through the game 5 times or more so far. There are plenty of reviews here that already tell you how the game plays, so I'll keep this brief.

It's a resource balancing game that also has a bit of hidden-identity discovery to it. There is no major story or plot to the game outside of short little vignettes and "event deck" stuff that happens which requires you to make a decision on. Every season you choose some people to raise or lower your resource bars, while hopefully finding out who to sacrifice without angering that sacrifice's house. Rinse and repeat 12 times, and you get an ending.

I also find it impotant to note that the game DOES come in multiple colors besides puke green. There is a purple/green variant and also a greyish black/red variant.

PROS
- Very cool aesthetic, reminds me a bit of Darkest Dungeon or Mike Mignola artwork.
- Nicely drawn cutscenes.
- Solid soundtrack, fits the mood perfectly.
- Overall interesting theme/concept as a whole.

CONS
- Lack of a real story, they really could've done something here. After a playthrough or two you just start clicking through everything and watching bars move up or down. This also means you're less invested in the "moral quandry" of the gameplay, because you start seeing everything as numbers instead of characters/people.
- The gameplay can be repeatitive if you're not into this kind of thing. Feels more like a game you'd play in short bursts.
- Not much variety in how you achieve the different endings.

OVERALL OPINION
Shrouded Isle is a really great game that doesn't quite reach its full potential. The 10 dollar price tag may feel a little steep for some if they don't intend on replaying it often. I personally didn't mind as I think we should throw our support behind original ideas and concepts even if the execution may not be as perfect as we would have liked in hopes that it inspires more original efforts.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award