The online world is the best of us and the worst of us. It connects and divides; it informs and actively spews misinformation. It is a place where people of all ages find enjoyment, belonging and entertainment; and it is filled with dangerous holes that take us to dangerous and nasty places.
It is little wonder that the division, misinformation, and dangers create real and appropriate concerns about the impacts on children - particularly when most children are far adept at using online spaces than many adults.
In this context there have been proposals for banning children from the internet from political leaders across Australia. The reaction is understandable - and keeping children safe from harm is something we should, as a community, not simply strive for, but achieve.
But is a social media ban the best way forward?
Probably not!
There are real questions about the practicalities of achieving a ban and around the additional data that would be placed in the hands of platforms.
Rather than a ban on children, serious regulation of platforms to require that they uphold their responsibility to keep children safe would be a preferable approach, but that is another story....
Our story - just published in Power to Persuade - focuses on what children have told us about their lives, particularly when they are growing up in poverty - with too little, and with far too few opportunities. In such contexts, children do often have devices - often bought by parents who desperately want their children to be connected and to have what their peers do. Children tell us about the lack of time with their parents (often because of parents' work and time burdens), they tell us about the lack of places to play, and a lack of things to do (often because lots of things cost too much).
The lack of places to play is not always about cost; it is also about poor planning, lack of infrastructure, and not feeling or being safe. Concerns about safety are not limited to online spaces - and very often children described feeling isolated and unconnected in their physical communities, of not knowing the adults around them, of not feeling respected or included. Little wonder they also talk about not feeling safe.
The debates around banning social media raise important questions not only about the nature of online communities, but also real, in-person communities - and the extent to which they are failing to serve many children.
In our Power to Persuade piece, my fabulous colleague Cadhla O’Sullivan and I ask not what we should ban, but what we need to put in place. Putting in place inclusive, supportive in-person communities for children, provides alternatives to online worlds, and has to potential to create relationships and webs of support that ensure children are no alone and isolated as they enter communities, either online or in-person.
https://lnkd.in/gBqNwZRk