I finally read Rick Rubin’s “The Creative Act: A Way of Being.” I liked it. It got me thinking about the question and ensuing argument, “Is advertising art?”
ADVERTISING IS ART
We’ve all seen the meme where Rubin states art “Isn’t about the audience.” Rubin says, “Art is the personal.” In advertising today, with multiple opinions, testing and layers of creative approval, ideas need to do some serious backflips for anything ‘personal’ to make its way through. The core insight probably remains but the personal has been sucked dry. When the rare personal makes its way through the gauntlet, it stands out, and companies are rewarded.
ADVERTISING IS NOT ART
Not all advertising is art. And that’s ok. I’ve made tons of NOT ART. NOT ART can be equally effective and amazing. Sometimes if a product is good or the strategy is good enough or the media buy is big enough it doesn’t NEED to be art or personal. Sometimes creatives can just use their talents to make the product/services look amazing, cool, delicious, fun, etc.
My final decision on if advertising can be art? A resounding “it can be.” Overall, I think the more of the ‘personal’ we can allow to stay in the work, the more it will connect with the audience, the more products and services will sell and the more promotions and fame our clients will get.
Marketing Manager at Fifth Ring
2moSeeing it with the 3D graphics was something else - especially once you see it in motion!