Elizabeth Aitken’s Post

View profile for Elizabeth Aitken, graphic

Principal at Empire Carbon and Energy

First expansion of the WEM, and the first sign of trouble... (sorry, behind a paywall again). Turns out that the construction of the 29km Malaga-Neerabup powerline announced late last year (remember this is the "easy stuff", the low hanging fruit), will clear will clear more than 150 hectares of bush including high-quality habitat for Carnaby’s black cockatoos. The plan will clear over 70 hectares of native vegetation, including parts of four different Bush Forever Sites, banksia woodland and a Conservation Category Wetland. This is according to documents released by the Environmental Protection Authority. You would think that #WesternPower would do better than this on approvals for the first #SWISDA project - a "priority project" that the ERA do not get to approve - only the Energy Minister. The tone will be set based on how Whitby juggles this first conflicting decision as both Minister for Energy and Minister for the Environment... https://lnkd.in/gD-7zyTE #WEM

Power line puts cockatoo homes up in the air

Power line puts cockatoo homes up in the air

thewest.com.au

Neil Canby

Executive Director at Sunrise Energy Group

6mo

If this is required for NREP then 2027 is at risk. Not a great way to start, picking a line route with significant environmental impacts and community groups in disagreement

Rob Phillips

Vice-chair of Sustainable Energy Now - previously Associate Professor in Educational Design at Murdoch University

6mo

Fraser Maywood I've had a look at this, and it isn't as drastic as it has been made out. The new line is parallel to an existing line, consistent with Energy Policy WA's guidelines. The proposed route does impact on small amounts of high quality woodland, but most of it is through degraded bush - cleared pine plantations that the government promised to restore ~20 years ago, but didn't. The wetland is surrounded by the Ellenbrook railway line reserve, so it's hardly pristine. Nevertheless, I question why there needs to be a cleared area 30m on either side of the proposed line. Part of that will be the existing line, and why does the other side have to be so wide. Maybe it's just outdated WP policies, that should be modernised. All in all, this seems to be an exemplar of the 'new way of doing things' - a balance between enabling renewables to combat climate change while protecting threatened environments as much as possible. Just think how much things have changed over the last decade. Back then, WP would simply have run the transmission line in the cheapest way to solve the engineering problem. Rob

Clowns that can juggle

Like
Reply
See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics