Steven Kuyan’s Post

View profile for Steven Kuyan, graphic

Reversing Obesity for Medicare & Medicaid Patients

Exciting news about the potential of GLP-1 RAs in reducing obesity-related cancer risks! As someone with multiple family members affected by cancer, this area of research is deeply personal. However, it's important to approach these findings with a "dose" of caution. While the study offers signals that are positive, we must recognize the limitations and avoid prematurely signaling these results as definitive to prevent a further rush on the drugs when there is already a shortage. The reliance on data from the TriNetX database, the exclusion of certain patient populations, and the inherent limitations of propensity score matching all point to areas where further review is needed. Also, the paradoxical finding that GLP-1 RAs offer superior mortality benefits despite less weight loss compared to bariatric surgery raises an area for further discussion. It's essential that to balance enthusiasm with a criticism and not fall into an area of confirmation bias one way or the other! https://buff.ly/45vQJWE #GLP1RA #Healthcare #EvidenceBasedMedicine #AOMs #WeightLoss

Comparative risk of obesity-related cancer with glucagon-like protein-1 receptor agonists vs. bariatric surgery in patients with BMI ≥ 35

Comparative risk of obesity-related cancer with glucagon-like protein-1 receptor agonists vs. bariatric surgery in patients with BMI ≥ 35

meetings.asco.org

Tzvi Doron, DO

Healthtech Exec Committed to Patient-First Innovation | Ro Employee #3 | Startup Leader | Strategic Advisor | Builder of High-Performing Teams

2mo

We need many more details to understand this study itself notwithstanding your caveats about propensity score matching. How long did people have obesity? What were their family histories? What other risk factors did they have? And many other questions... Much more research will have to be done to disentangle these questions, but we cannot exclude weight-independent effects of both bariatric surgery and GLP-1s as possible protective factors. For example, we know bariatric surgery changes hormone levels (ghrelin is most notable in LSG while GLP-1 is most notable in RYGB), the microbiome, and bile acid levels just to name a few. On the other hand, GLP-1s affect many organs, including the brain, heart, kidneys, etc. and also have positive impacts on systemic inflammation (they lower CRP). I still agree the findings of greater protection from GLP-1s than surgery are surprising and something that shlould give us pause before overinterpreting.

Like
Reply

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics