In response to Murari Kumar Jha op-ed in TheWire.in titled, "Swanky Buildings and ‘Net Zero’ Academics is Modi’s Model for Nalanda University", I find it necessary to address the skepticism surrounding Nalanda University's revival. Criticism should be healthy, not baseless. let's explore why this initiative deserves more than mere cynicism.
1. The Uncertainty Fallacy:
Jha's assertion that Nalanda University is an "uncertain project" lacks nuance. Every ambitious endeavor carries risks, but that doesn't render it futile. The uncertainty lies not in the project itself but in our ability to execute it effectively. Let's focus on mitigating risks rather than dismissing the entire venture.
2. Investment in Bihar's Progress:
#Bihar, despite its historical significance, grapples with socio-economic challenges. #nalandauniversity isn't a frivolous expense; it's an investment in Bihar's intellectual and economic growth. By nurturing talent, fostering research, and promoting innovation, it can uplift the state and the nation.
3. Beyond Swanky Buildings:
Yes, the media showcases the campus aesthetics, but that's only part of the story. Nalanda's purpose extends beyond architecture. It aims to create a vibrant academic ecosystem, attracting scholars, researchers, and students. Let's appreciate both form and substance.
4. So called Net-Zero:
The net-zero concept isn't mere greenwashing. It reflects our commitment to sustainability. Nalanda educates students about environmental stewardship, influencing future leaders. A campus that balances aesthetics with eco-consciousness benefits Bihar and the planet.
5. Media's Role:
Jha's criticism highlights media's responsibility. Blind worship or relentless negativity harms democracy. Let's encourage informed discourse. Constructive questions are essential, but let's avoid undermining transformative initiatives.
The Nalanda University isn't uncertain; it's a beacon of hope. Bihar deserves quality education, and this project aligns with that vision. Let's critique with purpose, recognizing that progress requires bold steps. Nalanda isn't just about buildings; it's about Bihar's and #India's resurgence.
- Avinash Kumar (personal opinion)
#TheWire #University #Education #News #Indiatoday #Republic #TimesofIndia #TheHindu #UPSC #CivilServices #Media
Vice President & Head, ESG -Asia Pacific
3wHaving lived in Mumbai and experienced flood during the monsoon season, this Design Callenge is certainly responding to the critical issue facing the informal settlement. Acting now to develop a sustainable and resilient housing solution is a clarion call to protect vulnerable communities.