Sr. Product Manager at Lama Freight | Record-breaking, National Championship winning Competitive Swimmer
EDIT: TL;DR: Achlanes High School swimmers can’t swim a meet because of a technical issue with the meet entry system and NCS/CIF would not let them swim even though they had done their due diligence to enter the meet. #letdonsswim While I think the commissioners failed in their mission statement, I’m here mainly to talk about the root of the issue. The tech. As a swimmer, I’m livid. I would be upset that a technical error took my chances to swim at championships. As a product manager though, I am trying to think of why ClubAssistant didn’t have a feature implemented giving a confirmation if you entered as a coach? That's bad user design. Simple user story: As a user, I would like to know my entries are confirmed so I don’t show up to a meet realizing my entry wasn’t valid. Getting confirmation through a psych sheet 2 days after entries close is not acceptable, untimely and causes issues for the user, in this case. Just to add, it's not even from ClubAssistant, it's from the meet directors or whoever is at NCS. From what some commenters and coaches are saying, this is not like submitting an email with an attachment of entries. If I get a confirmation screen and email that I was able to enter a meet successfully on the other products, then why is this one an exception? Unfortunately I cannot test the product for myself and confirm the findings, but if this is the feedback I am seeing as someone working with ClubAssiatant, I would bring this up to the team and see what solutions are there right now. If the feedback from users also say that it’s confusing- then my next question is: “what can we do to make this more user friendly?” But I will also admit I am not perfect either. Sometimes a simple solution gets overlooked for being “too simple” or it doesn’t get caught until a user tests it and realizes: “this isn’t working the way it should”. That’s when it’s too late, just like how the issue is here. It’s something everyone can learn from. (This isn’t a new swim coach for the team. This coach has coached for 3 years at Acalanes.) **I am in no way affiliated with Acalanes High School. EDIT: Software for swimming is honestly terrible and also a niche market, so I can see why user improvements and user design aren't exactly a priority. #sportstech #userstory #casestudy #pm #product #productmangement
I vouch the software swimming is a nightmare. The Fast Swim we use wants me to pull my hair because it is not flexible and they need to have different scenarios to allow the registration of swimmers
Sr. Product Manager at Lama Freight | Record-breaking, National Championship winning Competitive Swimmer
6moOn a side note- a lot of people have been emailing the commissioner to protest the decision. I will not put the email links up here to prevent possible spam and doxxing. I do blame the NCS team for not making an exception or making it right and not responding to emails on weekends to check if a championship meet was ok and entered correctly. However, I also want to say the actual ClubAssistant product to enter high school meets is flawed and this situation would not happen if someone even created a workflow to have an email confirmation or a screen to show: “registration complete.”