Joost Fanoy’s Post

View profile for Joost Fanoy, graphic

Attorney at Law (partner) | EU & Competition at BarentsKrans

Another win for the BarentsKrans Competition Litigation team this week, now in our Air cargo proceedings and regarding the overcharge methodology and the data to be used. Our client (Equilib), together with the other claimant (SCC), argued for a “one-step model” that was based on transaction data supplied by shippers. The airlines said there should be a “two-step model,” where first economists needed to determine the increase in what airlines charged freight-forwarders, and then to what extent this was passed on to the shippers. In its judgment, the court backed our model, saying it could produce “sufficiently reliable results”. The court also noted the airlines’ data might not be comprehensive enough to sustain this model. Another issue was if the overcharge should be assessed on the level of the surcharges (as argued by the airlines), or in relation to the total price of the airfreight services (as argued by the claimants). Also on this issue, the court sides with the claimants. Great teamwork of the BarentsKrans team (Martijn van Maanen, Tom Hoyer, Sophie Gilliam and myself), our funder Claims Funding Europe (Charles Wright, Roisin Lyng, Martin Hyde and Oscar McLaren) and The Brattle Group (Nicholas Powers and James Reitzes). Also a big thanks for the pleasant teamwork with Brande & Verheij LLP (counsel of SCC, Theodoor Verheij and his team) and Oxera Consulting LLP (Gunnar Niels and Lirio Barros). The judgment is not yet published but feel free to drop me a DM if you want to know more regarding the judgment or the case. BarentsKrans #competitionlitigation #dedicated

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics