Keith Whitchurch’s Post

View profile for Keith Whitchurch, graphic

President Director PT SMG Consultants

The annual Fraser Insititute survey of mining perceptions is out. As usual its being widely quoted. I suggest to everyone to look at page 5 of the report “Survey methodology” . It shows that out of just over 2000 questionnaires sent out only 206 full responses were received. Jurisdictions needed a minimum of 5 responses to be included. Jurisdictions with between 5 and 9 responses are noted. Given its a survey of “Perception” and not research into fact it is , by design, subjective. It would only take me and four friends to sit and reply with glowing perceptions about a jurisdiction to materially influence rankings. By same token people sitting in one part of the world with little or no experience of another jurisdiction may have their own perceptions of that other jurisdiction and so influence the survey. It’s not a report that should be relied upon for investment decisions

View profile for Greg McNab, graphic

Corporate & Securities Partner at Dentons | Helping clients navigate global risks and opportunities | M&A | Mining, Energy, Climate & Financial Services | National Co-Leader of the Canadian Mining Group | Director CACC

I am a "the glass is half full" kind of person, so I take the quote "Canada home to 5 of the world's 10 most attractive mining jurisdictions" as a compliment. But there is always a "but"...and that is that "it has plenty of room to improve in terms of regulatory policies", according to a new survey conducted by the Fraser Institute. Not surprisingly, uncertainty around protected areas and disputed land claims are major areas of concern for Canadian jurisdictions, the report said. For example, more than half of the respondents from B.C., Ontario and Nova Scotia indicated that uncertainty concerning disputed land claims was a deterrent to investment, compared with only nine per cent in Nevada and zero per cent in Utah. The mine is where the mine is, so we have our work cut out for us here in Canada.

Canada home to 5 of the world's 10 most attractive mining jurisdictions

Canada home to 5 of the world's 10 most attractive mining jurisdictions

financialpost.com

Carlo Fortugno

CEO at DustAct Eltura Group | Making Mining Sustainable

4mo

Thanks for sharing. This raises questions about the reliability of such surveys in guiding investment decisions.

Like
Reply
Stewart Howe

Gold & Base Metal ASX Mining Company Non-exec Director, Mining Fund Investment Committee

4mo

Agreed Keith, the ranking has some expected outcomes and others very peverse. Alberta being ahead of Chile is ludicrous, you just can’t develop mines in Alberta.

See more comments

To view or add a comment, sign in

Explore topics