Skip to main contentSkip to navigation

Christmas taste tests

From a cake-scoffing vicar to comedians pulling crackers, we test the essential items on the festive table

  • Ruby Bhogal

    Christmas cakes, bakes and desserts – tested by Ruby Bhogal

    The 2018 Bake Off finalist and food writer tastes and rates black forest mince pies, tiramisu panettone and winter orange cheesecake
  • Poppy O'Toole

    Christmas cheese, chutney and chocolate – tested by Poppy O’Toole

    Chef and TikTok’s Poppy Cooks rates centrepiece stiltons, truffled sheep’s cheese and festive flavoured chocolates
  • Jessie and Lennie Ware 
Styling: Hope Lawrie
Hair: Patrick Patrick Wilson at The Wall Group 
Makeup: Francesca Brazzo at The Wall Group using Charlotte Tilbury Beauty
Jessie wears: 
Red dress, £715, Roland Mouret at matchesfashion
Gold and pearl earrings, Completed Works, completedworks.com
Lennie wears:
Dress her own
Earrings, Alighieri, alighieri.com

    Christmas party food and drink – tested by Jessie and Lennie Ware

    The Table Manners podcasters give their verdict on festive snacks, crisps and booze
  • Anna

    The best Christmas chocolate and cheese – tested by Anna Haugh

    The MasterChef the Professionals judge samples vintage cheddar, fruity chutney and more
  • Rav

    The best Christmas cakes and bakes – tested by Ravneet Gill

    The Junior Bake Off judge rates mince pies, stollen and panettone
  • Ed

    The best Christmas party food and drinks – tested by Ed Gamble

    The Great British Menu judge’s verdict on crisps, bites and booze
  • Ravinder Bhogal and Jay Rayner

    The Christmas taste test challenge: the chef v the critic

    Ravinder Bhogal and Jay Rayner eat their way through the supermarkets’ mince pies, cheese, chocolates and more.
  • Mince pies

    Proof is in the pudding: M&S and Waitrose win Christmas food test

    Tasters compile league table of items such as turkey, gravy and yule logs from 52 stockists
  • Zoe Adjonyoh, Monica Galetti and Claire Ptak, the judges of this year’s taste tests.

    OFM’s great Christmas taste test 2018

    Mince pies, cheese, chocolate, party food – our three wise women guide you through the best high street offerings
  • Observer Food Monthly Christmas taste test
(L-R): Richard Turner and Jeremy Lee as the Ugly Sisters, Olia Hercules as Cinderella and Andi Oliver as the Fairy Godmother

Styling: Hope Lawrie 

Hair + Makeup (Olia): Ellie Tobin using Estée Lauder 
Makeup (Andi): Alex Golshahi using Rodial and Fenty Beauty.
Makeup (Richard and Jeremy): Celine Nonon at Terri Manduca using TBC

Pumpkins courtesy of Natoora (natoora.com)


OFM 
Xmas 2017

    The great Christmas taste test 2017

    Observer Food Monthly’s bumper review of high street cheese, chocolates, pies, cakes, puddings and more. And yes, our star reviewers shall go to the ball …
  • Gizzi Erskine as Nancy, Fergus Henderson as Mr Bumble, Gary Usher as the Artful Dodger and Giorgio Locatelli as Bill Sikes

    The great Christmas 2016 taste test

    Observer Food Monthly’s cast of Dickensian players feast on the high street’s cakes, cheese and chocolates. Which are the best buys? And did anyone ask for more?
  • Jay Rayner as Bad Santa for OFM November 2016

    Taste test: Christmas sandwiches

    Who better to sample sackfuls of festive-season sandwiches than our own Jay Rayner?
  • Sliced Smoked Salmon

    Supermarket smoked salmon: the best and worst – taste test

    If you’re serving salmon this Christmas, should you play it safe with traditional oak-smoked or take a gamble on maple syrup, seaweed or even whisky and ‘gold’ varieties? We put this year’s supermarket offerings to the test
  • Gary Lee, Patricia

    OFM’s Christmas taste test 2015

    High street turkeys, cheese, chocolates and cakes tasted and rated by top chefs for Observer Food Monthly
  • Tug luck: our tasting panel (clockwise from left) Falco, Kate Carpenter, Adrian Priestman, Sebi Sahillioglu, Lee Williams, Laura Rosa and Mannix.

    ‘I give them a 10 out of five’: chocolate stocking fillers – taste test

    Two families get on board to sample festive novelty chocs. Which will rock their boat?
  • Lianne Sanderson, Lucy Bronze, Eniola Aluko and Siobhan Chamberlain get stuck in.

    'It might go OK with KFC': England women’s football team test prosecco and mince pies

    The Lionesses have had plenty to celebrate this year, so who better to rate festive fizz? We put the players through their paces with prosecco, and they soak up the booze with some half-time pies
  • Royal Mail workers at the Mount Pleasant mail centre, London
Photograph by Felix Clay

    Signed, sealed and delivered: posties test Christmas cake

    From brandy-soaked fruit to (shock horror) chocolate, and topped with everything from nuts, cherries and marzipan to candied orange slices and penguins, our postal workers have sorted your iced Yuletide fruit cake selection
  • Children from Mile End Community Project and Tower Hamlets SocietyLinks put Christmas biscuits to the test.

    Christmas biscuits tested by teenagers: ‘I like it, man. It’s pure sugar’

    No Christmas is complete without a family-size box of biscuits, so our biccie boffins tried out some festive confections. But as biscuit tins were prised open, euphoria, nostalgia and disappointment poured out. That’s the way the (Christmas) cookie crumbles...
  • Lidl jamon serrano

    Aldi and Lidl’s best and worst luxury Christmas food – taste test

    This Christmas, you can buy luxuries such as lobster, caviar and fine wines from the discount supermarkets. But can they compete on taste as well as price? Tony Naylor finds five festive steals and five false economies
  • Solids crew: the Mother Goose cast taste novelty chocolate

    Taste test: the Mother Goose kids nosh novelty chocolate

    While the older cast members were enjoying their bubbly, we got the Hackney Empire panto’s young ‘uns to rate the Christmas chocolate that makes them melt
About 36 results for Christmas taste tests
12
  翻译: