We were just as shocked and disappointed as anyone after learning the news of Foxtrot/Dom's closing yesterday. Foxtrot was important to not only heywell, but the broader entrepreneurial community. Kerry Diamond asked the provocative question: "What does this say about modern CPG. Have we hit peak CPG? Has the bubble burst?" Our strong point of view is NO. Innovation is fundamental to commerce, for the simple reason that consumer needs evolve and the market will always look to solve them. And while innovation has seen a sharp decline across CPG since 2020 (influenced by a number of factors including supply chain issues, high interest rates, lack of funding etc) the truth is "the categories with innovation are the categories that are growing (SPINS)"
This abrupt closure is a huge failure because there is a strong market need for this type of platform. Foxtrot was heywell's first retail account, and while we have grown well beyond those first few stores, it was an important launching pad for heywell and remained a notable destination for consumers, influencers, retailers and investors to find innovative emerging brands. The merchandising and marketing teams we worked with are exceptionally talented, hard working and creative people who have become close friends over the years. They worked tirelessly to put a spotlight on innovative brands. (who by the way, were not all launched flush with VC funding). We find how the Foxtrot/Dom's employees were treated and how this closure was executed quite appalling.
In our opinion, this is not a conversation only about ‘market need’ or ‘consumer price sensitivity’. The Foxtrot brand was appealing and consumers flocked to the stores. More importantly, senior leadership must be accountable to basic business fundamentals like profitable growth, margin, and issues like over expansion, or cash runway. You don't raise 160 million dollars and run full speed into a brick wall. We're sad the community has lost a key path to market for emerging brands and a beloved brand providing consumers a source of discovery. We hope investors, brands and retailers are paying attention to the right things here and lean in, not out, to innovation and founders with experience building their brands the right way. Crain's Chicago Business BevNET.com, Inc. SPINS Audarshia Townsend Andrea Hernández Ashley Selman Britt Dougherty
Foxtrot Market and Dom's Kitchen & Market are abruptly closing all stores, less than six months after the brands merged.
Dom's, Foxtrot closing all stores as parent company shutters
chicagobusiness.com
Shipping Happiness Nationwide | Easy Corporate Gifting | Gourmet Business Gifting | Gifts of Gratitude | Sales Gifts | E-Commerce Director - Dorothy Lane Market | Your Secret Weapon for Sales Gifting
9moIn the end, the customers have to support their local treasures for them to survive. A customer just wrote my husband a letter and referred to Dorothy Lane Market as a “miracle”, she referenced the experience but most of all the customer service. She said she doesn’t feel as good anywhere like she does at the Springboro store. It’s not easy to combine all of these vital elements for independent grocers: Excellent customer service, quality food and a fun shopping experience, but it can be done.