In their recent publication, "Food systems interventions for #nutrition: lessons from six program evaluations in Africa and South Asia," authors Lynnette Neufeld, Stella Nordhagen, et al Evaluate six #foodsystem interventions in Africa and South Asia, and identify methodological challenges and provide recommendations for enhancing #evaluation quality.
Evaluated Programs:
Marketplace for Nutritious Foods:
Goal: Increase supply of nutritious foods in Kenya.
Interventions: Community of Practice (CoP) for training and networking, Innovation Accelerator for technical assistance and small grants.
SUN Business Network:
Goal: Support MSMEs to enhance the accessibility of nutritious food.
Interventions: Platform convening businesses, assessing needs, identifying support services, and advocating for business roles in addressing nutrition.
Workforce Nutrition (KFMW program):
Goal: Provide nutritious foods to vulnerable workers during COVID-19.
Interventions: Emergency grants for short-term food provision, light touch assessment for grant qualification, and monitoring plans.
Bhalo Khabo Bhalo Thakbo Campaign:
Goal: Promote healthier snack choices among adolescents in Bangladesh.
Interventions: Awareness campaign, online pledge for adolescents, and activities to support meeting pledge commitments.
Nigeria Egg Demand Creation Campaign:
Goal: Increase demand for eggs for young children.
Interventions: Above-the-line (ATL) and below-the-line (BTL) marketing strategies, personal engagement efforts.
Building Resilience of Nutritious Food MSMEs:
Goal: Ensure business continuity during and post-COVID-19.
Interventions: Emergency grants, training for financial and management challenges, and technical assistance for post-COVID-19 trade.
Key Challenges Identified:
1: Lack of an Evidence Base for Intervention
Recommendations: Conduct high-quality design evaluations before implementation, highlight poorly developed theories and logic gaps early, and include the intervention team in evaluation design.
2: Dynamic and Multifaceted Nature of Interventions
Recommendations: Use a theory of transformation, apply complexity-aware methods, document intervention adaptations, and reflect on adaptive processes for scalability.
3: Addressing Attribution
Recommendations: Use mixed methods, formulate clear research questions, utilize innovative methods like contribution analysis, and engage stakeholders to redefine attribution models.
4: Collecting or Obtaining Access to Accurate, Timely Data
Recommendations: Incentivize data sharing, train participants in record-keeping, collaborate with implementers for data collection timing, and develop practical tracking methods.
5: Defining and Measuring Appropriate Outcomes
Recommendations: Define and measure multiple outcomes, consider temporal and statistical factors, and broaden and model nutrition outcomes.
Read the paper here: https://lnkd.in/gDH85T5V
post by Nishita Panwar